Acid protease vs neutral protease: the pH, the unit and the label
Acid protease and neutral protease are separate enzymes with separate pH windows, assays and units. The acid preparation is specified at ≥100,000 U/g by a Folin-Ciocalteu assay at acid pH; the neutral one at ≥50,000 U/g by a casein assay near pH 7. A U/g figure belongs to its method, and a label that says only “protease” names neither enzyme.
Acid protease and neutral protease work at different pH values and are measured by different units, so one cannot replace the other on a label or in a blend.
Two mechanisms, two preparations
Acid protease is an aspartic endopeptidase, EC 3.4.23, with two catalytic aspartate residues. Neutral protease is a metalloendopeptidase, EC 3.4.24.28, with a zinc ion in its active site. The class difference explains the behaviour: the aspartic enzyme works in acid, and the metallo enzyme works near neutrality.
The CAS numbers differ too: 9025-49-4 against 9025-39-2. Each is a preparation with its own organism, process and carrier. A specification written for one does not describe the other, and a blend of both contains two enzymes that have to be declared separately.
The pH window is the working difference
| Line | Acid protease | Neutral protease |
|---|---|---|
| Enzyme class | Aspartic endopeptidase, EC 3.4.23 | Metalloendopeptidase, EC 3.4.24.28 |
| CAS number | 9025-49-4 | 9025-39-2 |
| Catalog activity | ≥100,000 U/g | ≥50,000 U/g |
| Assay pH | Acid, usually about 3.0 | Near neutral, usually about 7.0 |
| Working pH | Acid optimum near 2.5–3.5, useful to about pH 6 | pH 6.5–7.5 in 1% solution |
| pH of a 1% solution | Acidic | 6.5–7.5 |
| Effect of a chelator | No metal cofactor, so the activity is not removed by a chelator | The zinc is essential, so EDTA and similar agents can strip it |
Read the working pH before the assay pH. The first describes the blend; the second describes the certificate. A formulator needs both, and the gap between them is where most of the practical failures sit.
The unit is not transferable
A protease unit is a rate. Both assays may use casein and Folin-Ciocalteu detection, but they run at different pH values, so the numbers are not comparable. The substrate lot, temperature, time and standard move the result as well. No factor converts 100,000 U/g of the acid enzyme into a neutral figure.
Within one scale the arithmetic is exact: 1 kg at 100,000 U/g is 100 million units, and 2 kg at 50,000 U/g is also 100 million. That helps with ordering and blending, not with cross-enzyme conversion. If both activities are needed, each is calculated from its own certificate, and the totals are kept separate. The methods index covers the vocabulary.
What the label and the specification must say
Name each enzyme, its activity, its unit and its carrier. “Protease” alone is too broad when the specification or the label is meant to identify one enzyme, and a blend lists both. The activity figure carries its unit definition: 100,000 U/g and 50,000 U/g are different assays, not two strengths.
Regulatory status follows the preparation. A food-enzyme entry or a GRAS basis for one organism does not transfer to the other, and a supplement brand still confirms its dietary-ingredient route. The destination file should name the enzyme, organism, carrier and activity basis. When the label, the certificate and the market file use different names, the gap is a compliance issue before it is a labelling one.
What happens when both are in one formula
pH is the first interaction. Acid protease loses activity as the local pH rises; neutral protease loses activity outside its window. Alkaline salts such as calcium carbonate or magnesium oxide can push the acid enzyme out of range, while citric acid or ascorbic acid can push the neutral one out. Measure the blend pH at the start and after storage.
The chelator is the second. EDTA and similar agents can strip the zinc from the neutral enzyme without touching the acid one, so a blend may keep its acid activity and lose its neutral activity. Dose each enzyme against its own assay, add each at the point where it is stable, and declare both. The acid grade options are compared on the acid protease grades page.
Choosing between them
Start with the pH the enzyme will meet. An acid blend points to acid protease; a neutral blend points to neutral protease, unless a chelator rules it out. If the process crosses both windows, both may be useful, each with its own certificate.
Then check the dose and the pack. At 100,000 U/g the acid powder is twice as concentrated as the 50,000 U/g neutral grade, so the same unit target weighs half as much. A line that cannot weigh small charges may prefer the lower-activity product; a tight capsule fill may prefer the concentrate. The catalog entries are on the acid protease, neutral protease and alkaline protease product pages; the release workflow is on the quality page.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation