06 Identity & adulteration

How to prove a citrulline malate lot is 1:1

Technical document 06 · Reviewed 2026-11-20 · L-Citrulline Malate

On this page
  1. Five questions, five kinds of evidence
  2. Turning two results into a ratio
  3. What diffraction adds
  4. Substitution patterns
  5. Clauses that pin the identity
  6. Questions that produce evidence

A citrulline malate lot is the 1:1 material when four lines agree: the document names the ratio and CAS, HPLC and IR identify citrulline, the citrulline and malate results calculate to a 1:1 molar ratio, and the mass balance accounts for water and the counter-ion. The assay alone cannot do this, because a blend and a reacted salt can both read 99.0%. The ratio is the line that separates them.

In one line

Identity is the ratio proved from two results: citrulline by HPLC, malate by titration, and a molar quotient near 1.00, with water closing the balance.

Five questions, five kinds of evidence

Identity is not one test. Each line below answers a different question, and a supplier who stops at the document has shown intent rather than proof. The table maps the question to the evidence that settles it.

The evidence behind a 1:1 claim
LayerQuestionEvidenceWhat it settles
DocumentAre the name, ratio and CAS stated?Name, CAS number, formulaThe claim, not the powder
ChromatographyIs the amino acid citrulline?HPLC retention and IR spectrumThe molecule
RatioIs the grade 1:1?Citrulline and malate resultsThe grade
Mass balanceIs the powder diluted?Assay, loss on drying, impuritiesWhether the numbers add up
Solid formIs it a salt or a blend?X-ray diffractionThe physical state

A certificate with a name and an assay has answered the first row and part of the second. The ratio and the solid form are where a blend can pass as a salt, and they are the rows a one-number COA leaves blank.

Turning two results into a ratio

The theory is fixed. One citrulline unit at 175.19 g/mol and one malic acid unit at 134.09 g/mol make 309.28 g/mol, so a 1:1 salt is 56.6% citrulline and 43.4% malate. The catalog range of 55.0–60.0% citrulline is wide enough to cover normal manufacturing variation; it is not wide enough to define the grade on its own.

The calculation is short: divide the citrulline percentage by 175.19, divide the malate percentage by 134.09, then divide the first quotient by the second. At 57.0% citrulline and 42.0% malate the result is 0.3254 ÷ 0.3132 = 1.04. At 55.0% and 45.0% it is about 0.94; at 60.0% and 40.0% it is about 1.15. A ratio limit of 0.95–1.05 closes a gap that two separate ranges leave open.

Basis and method belong beside the numbers. Both results should be on the same moisture basis, and the malate method should be named: a titration measures acid groups and can count other acids, while HPLC is more specific to malate. A 1:1 blend by mass would sit at 50% citrulline, below the catalog range, so the 1:1 sold here is molar. A certificate may also use the name L-citrulline DL-malate, because the malic acid is normally the racemic form; the specification and the label should agree on one name.

What diffraction adds

X-ray diffraction sees phases, not percentages. A physical blend of crystalline citrulline and crystalline malic acid can show two sets of reflections, while a reacted and dried salt may be a single phase or largely amorphous depending on the process. That is a different question from the ratio, and it can be the decisive one when a lot flows or dissolves unlike the retained sample.

It is not a release test on the catalog, and it does not measure the counter-ion. Ask for the pattern, the reference and the detection limit before accepting a line that says the pattern matches. A “conforms” statement without the pattern is a conclusion without evidence.

Substitution patterns

How a citrulline malate lot can be stretched
AdulterantWhat changesSignalTest
Added L-citrullineCitrulline up, malate downRatio above 1Both component results
Added malic acidCitrulline down, acidity upRatio below 1 and lower pHMalate result
DilutionAssay and citrulline downMass balance does not closeAssay, loss on drying, ash
Arginine or ornithineCitrulline overstated on a short runExtra peak or poor resolutionChromatogram, mass spectrometry
WaterAs-is assay downLoss on drying up, dried assay normalLoss on drying

Colour is the easiest signal to fake: white to off-white is a broad target and a diluent can match it. The ratio and the mass balance are harder to reproduce, which is why a certificate that reports one assay and no ratio has not tested the most likely substitution.

Clauses that pin the identity

  • “L-Citrulline malate 1:1 (molar), CAS 54940-24-2, C6H13N3O3·C4H6O5.”
  • “Assay 98.0–101.0% by HPLC; state whether the figure is as-is or dried.”
  • “L-Citrulline 55.0–60.0%; calculated citrulline:malate molar ratio 0.95–1.05.”
  • “Loss on drying ≤1.0%; particle size ≥95% through 80 mesh.”
  • “Heavy metals and microbiology as listed on the catalog sheet.”
  • “Malate source declared; no added citrulline or malic acid beyond the declared ratio.”
  • “Destination market and label name confirmed before the order.”

Questions that produce evidence

  1. Which ratio does the certificate describe, and is it molar or by mass?
  2. What are the citrulline and malate results for this lot, by which methods and on which basis?
  3. What molar ratio do those two results calculate to?
  4. What is the loss on drying, and which basis does the assay use?
  5. Will you provide the chromatogram, the XRD pattern where relevant, and a joint re-test on the retained sample if the lot is disputed?

Five answers of this kind make an identity file; one assay percentage does not. The product hub holds the catalog specification; the COA page shows where each figure sits on the certificate; the grade page compares the ratios; the level-four comparison covers the label consequences; the methods library explains the assays; the quality page describes the release file.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation