How to prove a citrulline malate lot is 1:1
A citrulline malate lot is the 1:1 material when four lines agree: the document names the ratio and CAS, HPLC and IR identify citrulline, the citrulline and malate results calculate to a 1:1 molar ratio, and the mass balance accounts for water and the counter-ion. The assay alone cannot do this, because a blend and a reacted salt can both read 99.0%. The ratio is the line that separates them.
Identity is the ratio proved from two results: citrulline by HPLC, malate by titration, and a molar quotient near 1.00, with water closing the balance.
Five questions, five kinds of evidence
Identity is not one test. Each line below answers a different question, and a supplier who stops at the document has shown intent rather than proof. The table maps the question to the evidence that settles it.
| Layer | Question | Evidence | What it settles |
|---|---|---|---|
| Document | Are the name, ratio and CAS stated? | Name, CAS number, formula | The claim, not the powder |
| Chromatography | Is the amino acid citrulline? | HPLC retention and IR spectrum | The molecule |
| Ratio | Is the grade 1:1? | Citrulline and malate results | The grade |
| Mass balance | Is the powder diluted? | Assay, loss on drying, impurities | Whether the numbers add up |
| Solid form | Is it a salt or a blend? | X-ray diffraction | The physical state |
A certificate with a name and an assay has answered the first row and part of the second. The ratio and the solid form are where a blend can pass as a salt, and they are the rows a one-number COA leaves blank.
Turning two results into a ratio
The theory is fixed. One citrulline unit at 175.19 g/mol and one malic acid unit at 134.09 g/mol make 309.28 g/mol, so a 1:1 salt is 56.6% citrulline and 43.4% malate. The catalog range of 55.0–60.0% citrulline is wide enough to cover normal manufacturing variation; it is not wide enough to define the grade on its own.
The calculation is short: divide the citrulline percentage by 175.19, divide the malate percentage by 134.09, then divide the first quotient by the second. At 57.0% citrulline and 42.0% malate the result is 0.3254 ÷ 0.3132 = 1.04. At 55.0% and 45.0% it is about 0.94; at 60.0% and 40.0% it is about 1.15. A ratio limit of 0.95–1.05 closes a gap that two separate ranges leave open.
Basis and method belong beside the numbers. Both results should be on the same moisture basis, and the malate method should be named: a titration measures acid groups and can count other acids, while HPLC is more specific to malate. A 1:1 blend by mass would sit at 50% citrulline, below the catalog range, so the 1:1 sold here is molar. A certificate may also use the name L-citrulline DL-malate, because the malic acid is normally the racemic form; the specification and the label should agree on one name.
What diffraction adds
X-ray diffraction sees phases, not percentages. A physical blend of crystalline citrulline and crystalline malic acid can show two sets of reflections, while a reacted and dried salt may be a single phase or largely amorphous depending on the process. That is a different question from the ratio, and it can be the decisive one when a lot flows or dissolves unlike the retained sample.
It is not a release test on the catalog, and it does not measure the counter-ion. Ask for the pattern, the reference and the detection limit before accepting a line that says the pattern matches. A “conforms” statement without the pattern is a conclusion without evidence.
Substitution patterns
| Adulterant | What changes | Signal | Test |
|---|---|---|---|
| Added L-citrulline | Citrulline up, malate down | Ratio above 1 | Both component results |
| Added malic acid | Citrulline down, acidity up | Ratio below 1 and lower pH | Malate result |
| Dilution | Assay and citrulline down | Mass balance does not close | Assay, loss on drying, ash |
| Arginine or ornithine | Citrulline overstated on a short run | Extra peak or poor resolution | Chromatogram, mass spectrometry |
| Water | As-is assay down | Loss on drying up, dried assay normal | Loss on drying |
Colour is the easiest signal to fake: white to off-white is a broad target and a diluent can match it. The ratio and the mass balance are harder to reproduce, which is why a certificate that reports one assay and no ratio has not tested the most likely substitution.
Clauses that pin the identity
- “L-Citrulline malate 1:1 (molar), CAS 54940-24-2, C6H13N3O3·C4H6O5.”
- “Assay 98.0–101.0% by HPLC; state whether the figure is as-is or dried.”
- “L-Citrulline 55.0–60.0%; calculated citrulline:malate molar ratio 0.95–1.05.”
- “Loss on drying ≤1.0%; particle size ≥95% through 80 mesh.”
- “Heavy metals and microbiology as listed on the catalog sheet.”
- “Malate source declared; no added citrulline or malic acid beyond the declared ratio.”
- “Destination market and label name confirmed before the order.”
Questions that produce evidence
- Which ratio does the certificate describe, and is it molar or by mass?
- What are the citrulline and malate results for this lot, by which methods and on which basis?
- What molar ratio do those two results calculate to?
- What is the loss on drying, and which basis does the assay use?
- Will you provide the chromatogram, the XRD pattern where relevant, and a joint re-test on the retained sample if the lot is disputed?
Five answers of this kind make an identity file; one assay percentage does not. The product hub holds the catalog specification; the COA page shows where each figure sits on the certificate; the grade page compares the ratios; the level-four comparison covers the label consequences; the methods library explains the assays; the quality page describes the release file.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation