What the COA for L-citrulline malate 1:1 actually contains
A certificate for L-citrulline malate 1:1 has to report two quantities, not one: the salt assay and the L-citrulline content, with the malate figure that closes the ratio. The catalog sets the assay at 98.0–101.0% by HPLC, the L-citrulline content at 55.0–60.0% and the loss on drying at ≤1.0%. A certificate that shows only the assay has not shown which ratio was released.
The assay and the L-citrulline content are two different numbers, and the ratio between citrulline and malate is what makes the name 1:1 mean something.
Reading the certificate line by line
Every row on a useful certificate answers three questions: what was measured, how, and against which limit. For a salt with two components there is a fourth: what the percentage is a percentage of. A COA that lists numbers without methods and bases cannot be audited, however clean the numbers look.
| Parameter | Method | Release limit |
|---|---|---|
| Appearance | Visual | White to off-white powder |
| Identification | HPLC retention and IR spectrum | Conforms to the reference |
| Assay | HPLC | 98.0–101.0% |
| L-Citrulline content | HPLC | 55.0–60.0% |
| Loss on drying | Gravimetric | ≤1.0% |
| Heavy metals | ICP-MS | Pb ≤3 · As ≤2 · Cd ≤1 · Hg ≤0.1 mg/kg |
| Microbiology | Plate count and absence tests | APC ≤1,000 cfu/g; yeast and mould ≤100 cfu/g; E. coli and Salmonella absent |
| Particle size | Sieve analysis | ≥95% through 80 mesh |
The 80 mesh line is a finishing specification, finer than the 40 mesh used for the free amino acid. A mill or sieve change moves the result without touching the chemistry, so the result column needs the measured percentage rather than a tick.
Two percentages and the moisture between them
An assay near 99% beside a citrulline content near 56% can look contradictory until the basis is clear. The two figures describe different things: the assay describes the salt, and the citrulline result describes one component of it. The remaining mass is malate, not impurity. In a 1:1 molar salt, 175.19 g of citrulline plus 134.09 g of malic acid gives 309.28 g, so the theoretical split is 56.6% citrulline and 43.4% malate.
Moisture sits between the two readings. A 97.5% as-is assay with 0.8% loss on drying calculates to 98.29% on the dried basis (97.5 ÷ 0.992). The ≤1.0% limit keeps that gap small, but it is not zero: at 1.0% water the same as-is figure becomes 98.48% dried, and at 0.3% it is 97.79%. The basis has to be printed beside the number, not left to a footnote.
The ratio is a calculation, not a third measurement. Divide the citrulline percentage by 175.19 and the malate percentage by 134.09, then divide the first quotient by the second. A lot at 57.0% citrulline and 42.0% malate gives 0.3254 ÷ 0.3132 = 1.04. That quotient belongs on the certificate when the grade is part of the purchase.
Gate, result and the distance between
Each specification line has a gate and a result. The gate is the boundary; the result is what the laboratory measured. A row that repeats the limit has told the reader nothing about the lot, and it hides how much room was left before the next batch would fail.
| Parameter | Release limit | Result column |
|---|---|---|
| Assay | 98.0–101.0% | A measured percentage, its basis and the method |
| L-Citrulline | 55.0–60.0% | A measured percentage on the same basis as the assay |
| Loss on drying | ≤1.0% | A measured percentage |
| Heavy metals | Per element | A measured figure in mg/kg for each element |
| Microbiology | Counts and absence | The count and the absence statement for the lot |
A loose pair of component limits does not pin the grade. At 55.0% citrulline and 45.0% malate the molar ratio is about 0.94, and at 60.0% citrulline and 40.0% malate it is about 1.15. Both could pass two wide ranges while describing different powders, which is why a calculated ratio line is worth adding.
Where lots drift
The ratio is the first variable. It moves when a supplier blends citrulline and malic acid instead of drying a reacted salt, and it can drift while the assay stays comfortably inside its range. Water is the second: the drying step and the pack both set it, and the tight ≤1.0% release limit means an opened pouch can exceed it within days in a humid room. The sieve is the third, and it moves with the mill and the mesh.
Malic acid source is a fourth variable that the certificate rarely shows. The synthetic route starts from maleic anhydride; the fermentation route uses a microbial process. Each carries its own impurity profile and origin statement, and a buyer who needs a non-GMO or fermentation declaration needs the route identified before the lot is booked, not after.
Colour is the weakest line. White to off-white is a wide window, and a tint can follow heat during drying, a trace of reducing sugar or the malate source. One tinted lot is not an identity failure; a trend across lots is a reason to ask for the batch record.
The independent panel
Outside testing earns its place when the source is new, the destination is regulated, the supplier does not calculate the ratio, or a result is disputed. The panel does not need to repeat every row: HPLC for citrulline and assay, malate by titration, loss on drying, ICP-MS for the metals and a micro count cover the release questions. Add X-ray diffraction when the solid form, rather than the assay, is in doubt.
The HPLC method has to separate citrulline from its structural neighbours. Arginine and ornithine sit close enough to co-elute on a short run, and a single peak at the right time is not proof if the resolution was never shown. Ask for the chromatogram and the system-suitability data.
Keep the chain of custody short and documented. The sample tested should be the retained sample, the report should carry the lot code and the detection limit, and a referee test should use the retained sample rather than a fresh scoop from the drum.
Six lines for a supplier comparison
Compare the name and the ratio basis, the assay and its basis, the citrulline and malate results, the loss on drying, the sieve and contaminant panels, and the documents that come with the pack. Two certificates that agree on assay but differ on ratio are not describing the same powder, even when both are technically within their own specifications.
The catalog specification is on the L-citrulline malate product page. The tests that separate a salt from a blend are on the identity page; the difference from the free amino acid is on the L-citrulline page; the HPLC method is described in the methods library; the release workflow is on the quality page.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation