02.1 Malate vs citrulline

L-citrulline malate vs L-citrulline: the ratio, the acidity and the label

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-20 · L-Citrulline Malate

On this page
  1. The ratio and its basis
  2. The acid the malate brings
  3. The powder a label figure needs
  4. What the label has to say
  5. When to choose which

Citrulline malate 1:1 is not a synonym for L-citrulline. The salt carries about 56.6% citrulline and 43.4% malic acid, so a citrulline figure on a label needs about 1.77 g of powder per gram, and the powder brings an acid load that the free amino acid does not. The ratio, the acidity and the label move together, and this page takes them in that order.

In one line

The ratio fixes how much citrulline a gram of powder carries, the malate fixes the acidity, and the label has to name the form and the figure it declares.

The ratio and its basis

The 1:1 salt is built from one citrulline molecule (175.19 g/mol) and one malic acid molecule (134.09 g/mol), so the pair weighs 309.28 g/mol and the citrulline fraction is 175.19 ÷ 309.28 = 56.6%. The malate is the other 43.4%. Those are fixed by the formula, not by the assay, and they are the numbers behind the 55.0–60.0% catalog range.

What “1:1” and “2:1” can mean
ReadingCitrullineMalateStatus
1:1 molar56.6%43.4%The material on this catalog sheet
1:1 by mass50.0%50.0%Below the 55.0–60.0% catalog range
2:1 molar72.3%27.7%A different grade with a different label figure
2:1 by mass66.7%33.3%Another reading of the same printed name

The second row is the reason “1:1” alone is not a specification. A blend at equal masses would sit at 50% citrulline and fail the catalog range, so the 1:1 sold here is molar. Ask for the word “molar” on the purchase order and on the certificate, and ask for the citrulline and malate results that calculate to it.

The ratio is a property of the powder, not a serving suggestion. A certificate that reports only an assay has not defined it, because two blends can meet the same assay with different citrulline fractions. The calculation is simple: citrulline percentage divided by 175.19, malate percentage divided by 134.09, and the quotient compared with 1.00.

The acid the malate brings

Malic acid has two carboxyl groups with pKa values near 3.40 and 5.11, so a 5% solution of the malate reads acidic. The free amino acid is close to neutral: its 5% solution sits at pH 5.0–7.0. The difference is not a trace; it is the second component of the salt doing what an acid does.

Per gram of citrulline, the 1:1 material delivers about 0.77 g of malic acid, and the 2:1 material about 0.38 g. That acid load is a formulation decision before it is an analytical one. It sharpens a fruit flavour in a stick pack, it reacts with a carbonate or bicarbonate in a dry blend, and it is a compatibility question for an enteric coating or an acid-sensitive active. In a capsule it is a question for the shell and for the moisture the fill can hold.

The acid is not a defect and it is not removed by buying a higher assay. A formulator who wants the citrulline without the acid wants L-citrulline, not a cleaner malate.

The powder a label figure needs

If the panel declares 3 g of citrulline, the 1:1 material needs 3 ÷ 0.566 = 5.3 g of powder, the 72.3% grade needs 4.2 g, and the free amino acid needs 3.0 g. If the panel declares 6 g of citrulline malate 1:1, the citrulline delivered is 6 × 0.566 = 3.4 g. If it declares 6 g of citrulline and the powder is the malate, the weight is 10.6 g.

Those figures decide the pack. A 500 mg capsule holds 283 mg of citrulline as the 1:1 salt, 362 mg as the 72.3% grade, or the full 500 mg as the free amino acid. A stick pack or a drink mix has room for a multi-gram serving; a capsule count rarely does. The arithmetic is the same in both directions, and it should be done before the fill weight is fixed, not after the artwork is approved.

None of these numbers is a recommendation about how much anyone should take. They are the conversions that keep the declared figure, the powder weight and the certificate consistent.

What the label has to say

The panel has to name the ingredient that is in the pack. “L-Citrulline” and “L-citrulline malate 1:1” are different declarations, and a tub of one cannot be sold under a panel that names the other. Where the panel declares citrulline and the powder is the malate, the derivation and the ratio belong in the specification and in the label review, because the quantity on the panel is not the quantity of powder on the filling line.

A ratio printed on the front of a pack needs its basis beside it. “2:1” reads as 72.3% citrulline on a molar basis and 66.7% on a mass basis, and the two are different products. A certificate may also write “L-citrulline DL-malate”, using the racemic malate name, while the label uses “citrulline malate”; the two names should be reconciled in the specification so the artwork, the certificate and the customs description agree.

In the EU, the US and the UK the declared ingredient and the declared quantity have to match the product, and the destination decides the format of the panel. The compliance page sets out the documents; the label decision itself belongs to the buyer's regulatory team.

When to choose which

Choosing the form for a new formula
If the panel or the process isChooseBecause
A panel that says L-citrullineL-citrullineThe name and the powder have to match
A panel that says citrulline malate 1:11:1 molar malateThe declared form is the salt
A flavoured stick or drink that wants acidityMalate, ratio statedThe acid is part of the flavour design
A blend with a carbonate or a sensitive activeL-citrullineNo added acid load
A 500 mg capsule at its fill limitL-citrullineAll of the fill is citrulline

Choose the 1:1 malate when the label names it, when the serving is measured in grams, and when the acid is wanted. Choose L-citrulline when the panel already says so, when the pack is a capsule at its fill limit, or when the blend cannot carry the acid. A switch in either direction needs a new specification, a new fill weight and a new label review; it is not a substitution at the weigh-up.

The catalog specification for the salt is on the L-citrulline malate product page; the parent comparison is on the grade page; the free amino acid is described on the L-citrulline page; the assay methods are in the methods library; the release workflow is on the quality page.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation