L-carnitine tartrate vs L-carnitine: carnitine content, water and fill
L-carnitine tartrate and L-carnitine base deliver the same carnitine cation at different masses: the tartrate is a 2:1 salt with 68.2% carnitine, so 500 mg of carnitine needs 733 mg of tartrate or 500 mg of base. The tartrate is the easier powder to run and the base is the smaller fill. Water behaviour, fill weight and the label name decide between them.
The tartrate delivers 68.2 g of carnitine per 100 g of powder and about 47% more fill weight than the base, and it takes up water more slowly; the base is the smaller capsule with the stricter pack.
What each powder actually contains
Carnitine is a zwitterion: a quaternary ammonium group and a carboxylate on the same molecule. The base is that molecule alone. The tartrate pairs two carnitine units with one L-tartaric acid unit, and the salt is 68.2% carnitine by mass. The rest is tartaric acid, not filler.
The catalog specifies the tartrate at 98.0–102.0% salt assay and 68.0–72.0% carnitine. The carnitine figure is the one that matters for a label conversion; the salt assay is the one that matters for release. A certificate that gives only the salt assay has not said how much carnitine the drum carries.
The conversion, with the lot number attached
The theoretical factor is 322.40 ÷ 472.49 = 0.682. Divide a declared carnitine mass by the lot's carnitine content to get the powder weight. For 500 mg: 500 ÷ 0.682 = 733 mg at the theoretical figure, 500 ÷ 0.695 = 719 mg at 69.5%, and 500 ÷ 0.685 = 730 mg at 68.5%.
Three details keep the calculation honest. Use the carnitine result from the lot certificate, not the middle of the catalog range. Keep the assay basis consistent: a carnitine figure on the dried basis is not the same as one on the powder as received. And write the calculation into the batch record, so the fill weight can be audited against the certificate.
Water: the tartrate is slower, not immune
Both powders take up water; the difference is rate and consequence. The base is hygroscopic, with a loss-on-drying limit of ≤0.5%, and it can soften and cake in an open pack. The tartrate carries a ≤1.0% limit and a counter-ion that reduces water uptake, so it tolerates a normal dose room for longer. Neither powder is a dry-room exemption.
In a capsule, water moves between the fill and the shell. A tartrate fill is less likely to pull water from the shell than a base fill, but a humid room still changes the fill weight and the flow. The pack, the liner and the time the pouch stays open decide more than the label on the drum.
Fill weight, bulk density and the shell
Fill weight is set by volume and bulk density, not by the carnitine figure alone. The tartrate needs 733 mg for 500 mg of carnitine, and that mass may not fit the shell that holds 500 mg of base. Size the shell for the tartrate first, then check the capsule count per serving and the label.
Bulk density is not fixed by the catalog, so ask for the lot figure and run a fill trial on the machine that will be used. An 80-mesh powder flows differently from a granulated grade, and a high-speed line may need the granulated form even though the milled powder assays the same. A fill trial can prevent a rejected batch.
What the label has to say
If the panel says L-carnitine, the declared mass is carnitine. If it says L-carnitine L-tartrate, the declared mass is normally the salt, and a carnitine figure beside it needs its own conversion and its own basis. The two panels can describe the same carnitine dose with different milligram figures, which is why the ingredient name and the number have to be read together.
A switch from base to tartrate is a label change, a fill change and possibly a capsule-count change. It is not a sourcing substitution. The brand's reviewer should see the new specification, the new certificate and the new calculation before the print run.
When to choose which
Choose the tartrate when the line needs flow, when the dose room is ordinary, when the label can name the salt, and when the heavier fill still fits the shell or the tablet. Choose the base when the smallest possible fill matters, when the label already says L-carnitine, and when the plant can hold a dry room and a sealed pack.
The tartrate product page carries the catalog specification, the grades page places this comparison in the wider range, the L-carnitine product page carries the base specification, the COA page shows how the two percentages are reported, the identity page covers the 2:1 ratio, and the stability page follows the water question into the pack. The methods index describes the HPLC and titration methods, and the quality page covers release.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation