Betaine anhydrous or betaine HCl: choosing a grade
Betaine anhydrous and betaine hydrochloride are different label ingredients, not two strengths of one material. The anhydrous inner salt is the betaine molecule itself, specified at 97.5–102.5% by titration, while the hydrochloride carries about 76% betaine and an acidic pH. The choice follows the betaine dose, the dosage form and the name the label can use.
The two forms deliver different amounts of betaine per gram and sit at different pH, so the grade follows the dose and the dosage form.
One molecule, two sold forms
Betaine is trimethylglycine: a glycine backbone with three methyl groups on the nitrogen and a carboxylate on the same molecule. That arrangement makes it an inner salt, electrically neutral overall but charged at both ends. The names betaine, trimethylglycine and TMG describe the same substance; betaine anhydrous describes the form with no water of crystallisation.
Betaine hydrochloride is a different salt. One equivalent of hydrochloric acid sits with the molecule, so the formula becomes C5H11NO2·HCl and the molecular mass rises from 117.15 to 153.61 g/mol. The extra mass is not betaine. It is the acid and the chloride, and it changes the pH, the hygroscopicity and the number the label has to declare.
The two forms side by side
| Property | Betaine anhydrous | Betaine hydrochloride |
|---|---|---|
| Formula | C5H11NO2 | C5H11NO2·HCl |
| CAS number | 107-43-7 | 590-46-5 |
| Molecular mass | 117.15 g/mol | 153.61 g/mol |
| Betaine per gram | all of the molecule | about 76.3% |
| pH (5% solution) | 5.0–7.0 | about 1 |
| Water limit | ≤2.0% loss on drying | — |
| Label name | Betaine anhydrous | Betaine hydrochloride |
| Usual format | Capsules, tablets, powder blends | Acidified powders and tablets |
The hydrochloride carries its own water limit on its certificate; the catalog limit here belongs to the anhydrous grade. The betaine figure for the hydrochloride is arithmetic, not a specification: 117.15 ÷ 153.61 gives 76.3%. A 1,000 mg label of betaine hydrochloride therefore supplies about 763 mg of betaine. The salt assay may sit in its own release window, but the betaine equivalent is lower by the mass of the acid.
pH, water and flow
The anhydrous form gives a 5% solution at pH 5.0–7.0, close enough to neutral that it does not disturb a simple capsule or tablet formula. The hydrochloride gives a solution near pH 1. That acidity is the point of the salt in some formulas and a problem in others: it can attack acid-sensitive actives, shift the taste of a stick pack and change the behaviour of an effervescent system.
Only one of the two is strongly hygroscopic. The anhydrous powder can cake in an open pouch as it takes up water, and the gain appears in the loss-on-drying result. The hydrochloride takes up less water at the same humidity, but it brings an acid load to the powder bed and to the solution. Neither should be left open between weighing and encapsulation.
Particle size is a separate variable. The catalog anhydrous grade is ≥95% through 30 mesh, with 60 mesh and granulated versions available on request. Flow, segregation and fill weight follow the mesh and the granulation, not the form alone. A change of form is not the right fix for a flow problem; a change of mesh or a granulated grade is.
The dose conversion
| Betaine target | Anhydrous needed | Hydrochloride needed |
|---|---|---|
| 500 mg | 500 mg | 655 mg |
| 1 g | 1 g | 1.31 g |
| 2 g | 2 g | 2.62 g |
The conversion is a multiplication by 1.311, the inverse of 76.3%. It is worth doing before the capsule size is chosen: 2 g of betaine as the hydrochloride is 2.62 g of powder, which may not fit the same capsule as 2 g of the anhydrous form. The same arithmetic applies when two quotations are compared by weight: the powder with the higher betaine fraction delivers more betaine per kilogram.
Write the basis into the purchase order. “Betaine anhydrous, 1,000 mg per capsule” and “betaine hydrochloride, 1,000 mg per capsule” are different products with different betaine contents, even though both labels can say 1,000 mg. If the label declares the salt, the betaine equivalent belongs in the specification and in the formula record.
What to write into the specification
- “Betaine anhydrous, CAS 107-43-7, C5H11NO2; not the hydrochloride.”
- “Assay 97.5–102.5% by titration, reported on the anhydrous basis, with the water result beside it.”
- “Loss on drying ≤2.0%; pH 5.0–7.0 in 5% solution; ≥95% through 30 mesh.”
- “Identity by IR; chloride absent or below the agreed limit.”
- “If betaine hydrochloride is supplied instead, the label name, the salt assay and the betaine equivalent must be declared.”
The form name is the first line for a reason. A specification that says only “betaine 98%” leaves the salt question open, and the certificate can then satisfy the number with either form. The label, the dose and the pH all follow from that one word.
When the other form is the right one
Choose the anhydrous form when the formula needs the highest betaine mass per capsule, a near-neutral solution or a powder blend that cannot take a strong acid. Choose the hydrochloride when the purchase order and the label name the salt, and when the acidified matrix is intended and has been tested with that acid load. Do not switch forms to solve a flow, taste or stability problem before the mesh, the excipients and the pack have been checked; the form change is a formulation change, not a processing tweak.
The detailed comparison of dose, pH and label wording is on the anhydrous versus hydrochloride page. The COA page shows what the certificate reports; the tests that separate the forms are on the identity page; water uptake and shelf life are covered on the stability page; the compliance page covers the label rules. The product page lists the catalog grade.
In this document
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation