02.1 HCl vs mononitrate

Thiamine HCl vs mononitrate: potency, water and the label

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-18 · Vitamin B1

On this page
  1. Two salts, one vitamin
  2. The potency arithmetic
  3. Water and the physical form
  4. Stability follows the matrix
  5. What the label has to say
  6. When to choose which

Thiamine hydrochloride and thiamine mononitrate deliver the same thiamine cation in different packages. The hydrochloride is about 78.7% thiamine by mass and the mononitrate about 81.1%, so the same milligram of thiamine needs a different weight of each salt. The hydrochloride carries a 5.0% water limit and an acidic solution; the mononitrate carries a 1.0% water limit and a near-neutral one. The label has to name the salt that is in the drum.

In one line

Same vitamin, different salt: 78.7% against 81.1% thiamine, a 5.0% against a 1.0% water limit, and a label that has to name which one is in the drum.

Two salts, one vitamin

The two commercial thiamine salts
PropertyThiamine hydrochlorideThiamine mononitrate
FormulaC12H17ClN4OS·HClC12H17N5O4S
CAS67-03-8532-43-4
Molecular weight337.27327.36
Counter-ionTwo chloridesOne nitrate
Assay, dried basis98.5–101.5% by titration98.0–102.0% (USP)
Water or loss on drying≤5.0% (KF)≤1.0% (LOD)

Both are permitted vitamin B1 sources in the EU, the US and the UK, and both are pharmacopoeial articles. The choice between them is not a question of which is more “natural” or more potent: it is a question of which salt survives the matrix and which one the label can name.

The potency arithmetic

The assay range does not tell a formulator how much thiamine is in a gram of powder. The molecular weight does. Thiamine hydrochloride is 337.27 g/mol against a thiamine cation of 265.36 g/mol, which gives 78.7% thiamine; the mononitrate is 327.36 g/mol, which gives 81.1%. The mononitrate is the more concentrated salt by about three percent, and that difference has to be worked into every dose.

Converting a thiamine claim into salt weight
Declared thiamineThiamine hydrochlorideThiamine mononitrate
1 mg1.27 mg1.23 mg
10 mg12.7 mg12.3 mg
100 mg127 mg123 mg

The same arithmetic runs in the other direction when a certificate reports a salt weight and the label declares thiamine. A certificate figure of 100 mg is a salt figure unless the basis says otherwise, and a supplier who quotes “100 mg thiamine” while shipping 100 mg of the hydrochloride is short by about 21% of the declared nutrient. The declared nutrient is thiamine; the weighed ingredient is the salt.

Overages are a separate decision. A formula may add extra salt to cover loss over shelf life, but the overage is calculated on the measured stability of the matrix, not on the salt-to-thiamine conversion. Mixing the two calculations produces a label that is neither the declared dose nor the tested dose.

Water and the physical form

The water limit is the clearest physical difference. The hydrochloride is hygroscopic and its monograph allows up to 5.0% water; the mononitrate is the low-hygroscopicity salt and its moisture limit is 1.0%. A hydrochloride powder left open in a humid room gains water, cakes and changes its as-is potency. A mononitrate powder in the same room is far less affected, which is why dry premixes, tablets and fortified flours usually specify the mononitrate.

Water also changes the assay arithmetic. A hydrochloride lot at 99.0% on the dried basis with 4.8% water carries about 94.2% salt as-is; the same lot at 1.0% water would carry about 98.0% as-is. The dried-basis result is the same, but the powder a formulator weighs is not. The mononitrate's tighter moisture limit makes the as-is figure more stable from lot to lot.

The pack has to match the salt. The hydrochloride needs a moisture barrier and a short working exposure; the mononitrate is more forgiving but still needs a sealed pack. Neither salt should be stored in an open container in a dispensary, and neither should be judged by the appearance of the top layer of a drum.

Stability follows the matrix

In the dry state the mononitrate is the more robust solid: it is less hygroscopic and does not pull water into a blend. In solution the order reverses. Thiamine is most stable in acid, and the hydrochloride keeps its 2.5% solution at pH 2.7–3.3; the mononitrate sits near neutral, where the molecule degrades faster, especially with heat. A beverage at pH 3–4 therefore favours the hydrochloride on both solubility and stability, while a dry tablet favours the mononitrate on water alone.

Heat, oxygen, light, copper and iron affect both salts, and sulfite cleaves both. Choline chloride in a premix is a known incompatibility, and the hydrochloride is the more affected form. The practical rule is that the salt choice and the process have to be tested together: a salt that is stable as a powder can still lose thiamine in a warm, wet matrix, and a salt that is stable in acid can still cake in a humid room.

What the label has to say

In the EU, Annex II to Directive 2002/46/EC lists “thiamin hydrochloride” and “thiamin mononitrate” as separate permitted forms, and the ingredient list has to use the name of the salt that is present. The nutrition declaration gives thiamine in mg and as a percentage of the 1.1 mg nutrient reference value. In the US, the Supplement Facts panel declares thiamine against a Daily Value of 1.2 mg and the ingredient list names the salt. The UK uses the retained permitted-forms list and a 1.1 mg reference value.

Switching the salt changes two things on the label: the ingredient name and the weight of salt behind the same thiamine figure. It does not change the declared nutrient, and it does not create a claim. A label that says “thiamine hydrochloride” over a mononitrate lot is a labelling defect even when the thiamine number is correct.

When to choose which

  • Acidic beverage or syrup at pH 3–4: the hydrochloride, for solubility and for the acidic pH it brings.
  • Dry tablet, capsule, premix or fortified flour: the mononitrate, for the lower water uptake and the tighter moisture limit.
  • Powder stick blended dry and dissolved by the consumer: either salt can work, but the hydrochloride dissolves faster and the mononitrate is more forgiving in the hopper.
  • Gummy or chew with a cook step: test both in the real matrix; the pH and the thermal load decide more than the salt name.
  • Existing label and stability file: the salt already named and tested is the default; a switch is a new specification and a new stability question.

This catalog is the hydrochloride, 40 mesh. The grade page places the choice in the wider range; the stability page covers the matrix effects; the identity page shows how the salt is proved; the compliance page covers the permitted names; the product hub carries the specification and the pack sizes.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation