Thiamine HCl or mononitrate: choosing a vitamin B1 grade
Vitamin B1 is sold as two permitted salts, thiamine hydrochloride and thiamine mononitrate. Both deliver the same thiamine cation, but the hydrochloride is 78.7% thiamine by mass and the mononitrate 81.1%, and the two carry different water limits, solubilities and hygroscopicity. The dosage form and the process decide which salt fits; this catalog is the hydrochloride, specified at 40 mesh, and the mononitrate would be a separate article.
The salt is chosen by the dosage form and the process, not by the assay number: hydrochloride where water is present, mononitrate where the powder must stay dry.
The grade is the salt, not the percentage
Both salts are pharmacopoeial articles with narrow assay ranges. Thiamine hydrochloride is specified at 98.5–101.5% on the dried basis, the mononitrate at 98.0–102.0% in the USP monograph, and both are white crystalline powders. The two ranges alone make the materials look interchangeable. They are not: the anion changes the mass fraction of thiamine, the water limit, the pH of the solution, the solubility and the way the powder behaves in a blender.
The grade also includes the physical form. The standard is a crystalline powder with at least 95% through 40 mesh; an 80 mesh or granulated version is available on request and is a different article for flow, dust and blend uniformity. A grade is therefore a salt plus a particle size, not a purity band.
The two salts side by side
| Property | Thiamine hydrochloride | Thiamine mononitrate |
|---|---|---|
| Formula | C12H17ClN4OS·HCl | C12H17N5O4S |
| CAS | 67-03-8 | 532-43-4 |
| Molecular weight | 337.27 | 327.36 |
| Thiamine by mass | About 78.7% | About 81.1% |
| Assay, dried basis | 98.5–101.5% by titration | 98.0–102.0% (USP) |
| Water or loss on drying | ≤5.0% (KF) | ≤1.0% (LOD) |
| pH, dilute solution | 2.7–3.3 (2.5%) | Near neutral (about 6–8) |
| Water solubility | Freely soluble | Sparingly soluble |
| Behaviour in air | Hygroscopic; picks up water when open | Low hygroscopicity; stable as a dry solid |
The hydrochloride solution is acidic because the salt carries two chlorides; the mononitrate solution is close to neutral. That difference drives the choice in liquids and in any matrix whose pH is already near the range where thiamine is least stable.
Converting between the salts
Thiamine is the declared nutrient; the salt is the ingredient. The conversion is a mass fraction, not an assay result. One milligram of thiamine hydrochloride carries about 0.787 mg of thiamine, and one milligram of the mononitrate carries about 0.811 mg. To declare 10 mg of thiamine, a formula needs about 12.7 mg of the hydrochloride or about 12.3 mg of the mononitrate.
| Salt | Thiamine per mg | Salt for a 10 mg thiamine claim |
|---|---|---|
| Thiamine hydrochloride | 0.787 mg | 12.7 mg |
| Thiamine mononitrate | 0.811 mg | 12.3 mg |
The arithmetic applies in reverse when a supplier quotes a salt weight against a thiamine label. A 10 mg certificate figure is a salt figure unless the basis says otherwise. Overages belong to the stability decision, not to the conversion.
Water, heat and the process
The hydrochloride is hygroscopic. Left open, it takes up water, and the water limit of 5.0% exists because the molecule can hold that much without failing the assay. The mononitrate is the low-hygroscopicity salt, with a 1.0% moisture limit, and it is the usual choice for dry premixes, direct-compression tablets and any blend that will sit in a hopper. In a dry blend the hydrochloride can cake, stall a feeder or transfer moisture to a sensitive partner.
In solution the ranking changes. Thiamine is most stable in acid, and the hydrochloride keeps its 2.5% solution at pH 2.7–3.3, inside the stable range. The mononitrate sits near neutral, where the same molecule degrades faster, and a mononitrate solution that is heated will lose thiamine sooner than an acidic hydrochloride solution. The dry solid and the dissolved salt are two different stability questions, and a grade chosen on dry behaviour alone can disappoint in a beverage.
Heat, sulfite and metal ions matter to both salts. Sulfiting agents cleave thiamine, copper and iron accelerate degradation, and a process that holds the material hot and wet is worse than a short dry blend. Choline chloride is a known incompatibility in premixes, and the hydrochloride is the more affected of the two salts.
Which dosage form takes which salt
Capsules and tablets usually take the mononitrate: the powder is less hygroscopic, flows better in a dry blend and does not pull water from the excipients. A hydrochloride tablet is possible, but the specification then has to control the room humidity, the excipient water and the compression step.
Powder sticks and drink mixes sit between the two. The hydrochloride dissolves freely and gives a clear solution, which a drink mix wants, but it picks up water in an open hopper and the acidic taste is noticeable. The mononitrate is more forgiving in the dry blend and the hopper, but it dissolves more slowly in the glass.
Gummies and chews are a water-and-heat process. The pH of the gummy mass, the cook temperature and the water activity decide the loss, and a salt that keeps the matrix acidic is an advantage. Functional beverages are the clearest case for the hydrochloride: a low-pH drink at pH 3–4 is already in the range where thiamine is most stable, and the salt dissolves without a carrier.
What the label has to say
In the EU, Annex II to Directive 2002/46/EC lists both forms as “thiamin hydrochloride” and “thiamin mononitrate”, and the ingredient list has to use the permitted name of the salt that is actually in the product. The nutrition declaration gives thiamine in mg and as a percentage of the nutrient reference value of 1.1 mg. In the US the Supplement Facts panel declares thiamine in mg against a Daily Value of 1.2 mg, and the ingredient list names the salt. The UK follows the retained permitted-forms list and a reference value of 1.1 mg.
Switching the salt changes the ingredient name and the weight needed for the same thiamine claim. It does not change the declared nutrient or create a new claim. The brand's label review still has to confirm the wording, and this page makes no health claim for either form.
What changes when the salt changes
A salt switch is a specification change, not a substitution. The purchase order should name the salt and the CAS number, the assay and its basis, the water limit, the pH range, the counter-ion tests, the particle size and the microbiological limits. The dose calculation and the label artwork follow. A product already on stability needs data for the new salt in the final matrix, because the water and pH behaviour differ even when the thiamine claim is identical.
The narrow comparison is on the hydrochloride versus mononitrate page; the full test sequence is on the identity page; the certificate lines are on the COA page. The product hub carries the catalog specification.
In this document
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation