02.1 Mononitrate vs HCl

Thiamine mononitrate vs hydrochloride: the salt, the water and the label

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-20 · Thiamine Mononitrate

On this page
  1. Two salts, one vitamin
  2. The water allowance
  3. Solubility and the solution
  4. Dry and wet behave differently
  5. The arithmetic between the salts
  6. The label and the declared nutrient
  7. When to choose which

Thiamine mononitrate and thiamine hydrochloride carry the same thiamine cation with different counter-ions: one nitrate against two chlorides. The mononitrate is 327.36 g/mol and 81.1% thiamine, holds a 1.0% loss-on-drying limit and gives a near-neutral solution; the hydrochloride is 337.27 g/mol and 78.7% thiamine, allows up to 5.0% water and gives an acid solution. The choice turns on water, solubility and the name the label has to carry.

In one line

Same vitamin, different counter-ion: about 3% less mass per milligram of thiamine, one fifth of the water allowance, and a label that must name the nitrate salt.

Two salts, one vitamin

The structural difference is the counter-ion. Thiamine is a thiazolium cation; the mononitrate pairs it with one nitrate ion, and the hydrochloride is the chloride salt with an additional hydrogen chloride, which is why its formula carries two chlorides. Both are pharmacopoeial articles and both appear on the EU permitted-forms list for vitamin B1.

Thiamine mononitrate against thiamine hydrochloride
PropertyThiamine mononitrateThiamine hydrochloride
CAS number532-43-467-03-8
FormulaC12H17N5O4SC12H17ClN4OS·HCl
Molecular weight327.36337.27
Counter-ionOne nitrateTwo chlorides
Thiamine content81.1% by mass78.7% by mass
Water limitLoss on drying ≤1.0%Water ≤5.0%
5% solution pH6.5–7.5About pH 3
Label nameThiamine mononitrateThiamine hydrochloride

Neither salt is an interchangeable substitute for the other: separate specification items, separate certificates, separate label names. A purchase order that says “vitamin B1” has not chosen either.

The water allowance

The moisture limit is the clearest physical difference. The mononitrate is the low-hygroscopicity salt and is released at loss on drying ≤1.0%; the hydrochloride is hygroscopic and its specification allows up to 5.0% water. Leave the hydrochloride open in a humid room and it takes up water, cakes and loses potency on an as-is basis; the mononitrate in the same room is much less affected. That behaviour is why dry blends, tablets and capsules generally use the nitrate salt.

Water also changes the weigh-up. Take two lots both at 99.2% on the dried basis: the hydrochloride with 4.0% water carries 95.2% salt as-is, while the mononitrate with 0.6% water carries 98.6%. The dried-basis results are the same; the powder on the balance is not. The tighter limit makes the as-is figure more predictable from lot to lot.

Both salts still need a sealed, light-resistant pack. Low hygroscopicity is a smaller water uptake, not a licence to store the powder open.

Solubility and the solution

The hydrochloride dissolves readily in water and is the usual choice where a clear solution is wanted. The mononitrate dissolves more slowly and to a lower concentration, so a concentrated stock made from it may need warming, longer mixing or a larger volume. For a stick pack or a drink mix at a normal dose, both salts dissolve in the consumer's glass; for a manufacturing concentrate, the difference is practical.

Solution pH matters as much as solubility. The mononitrate gives a near-neutral solution; the hydrochloride gives an acid one, and thiamine is most stable at acid pH. An acidic beverage therefore usually favours the hydrochloride. A mononitrate solution can be used if an acidulant brings the pH into the stable range and the hold time is validated.

Dry and wet behave differently

As a powder, the mononitrate is the tougher of the two: less water uptake, a tighter moisture limit and better behaviour in a blend. In solution the order reverses. The hydrochloride keeps the matrix acidic, where thiamine is more stable; the mononitrate sits near neutral, where heat, oxygen and light degrade it faster. A dry tablet therefore favours the mononitrate, and a beverage at pH 3–4 favours the hydrochloride.

Both salts are cleaved by sulfite and bisulfite, affected by copper and iron, and lose potency under heat and light. The salt and the process belong in one trial: a solid that survives the drum can still lose thiamine once the matrix is warm and wet.

The arithmetic between the salts

Because one mole of either salt carries one mole of thiamine, the conversion is a ratio of molecular weights. One milligram of thiamine needs 1.23 mg of the mononitrate or 1.27 mg of the hydrochloride. In the other direction, 100 mg of the mononitrate delivers 81.1 mg of thiamine and 100 mg of the hydrochloride delivers 78.7 mg. Per gram, the nitrate salt carries about three percent more thiamine.

The difference compounds at high doses: a 500 mg thiamine claim needs 617 mg of the mononitrate or 635 mg of the hydrochloride, which can decide a capsule size. The assay range is a second correction, so an overage is calculated on the measured result, not the label.

State the basis as well as the salt. A certificate figure is a salt figure unless it says otherwise, and a label figure is usually thiamine. Mixing them is the error that makes a correct assay produce an incorrect dose.

The label and the declared nutrient

In the EU, Directive 2002/46/EC places “thiamin mononitrate” and “thiamin hydrochloride” on the Annex II list as two distinct forms, and the ingredient list must say which one is in the product. The nutrition panel declares thiamine in mg and as a share of the 1.1 mg reference value. US labels declare thiamine in the Supplement Facts panel, where the Daily Reference Value is 1.2 mg, and name the salt in the ingredient statement. The UK applies retained labelling rules and its own reference value.

Switch the salt and two label facts move: the ingredient name, and the mass of salt behind the same thiamine number. The declared nutrient and the claim do not change. A pack that names the hydrochloride while holding the mononitrate is mislabelled, even if the thiamine figure is right.

When to choose which

  • Tablet, capsule, dry premix or fortified flour: the mononitrate, chosen for low water uptake and the 1.0% moisture limit.
  • Acidic drink, syrup or liquid concentrate around pH 3–4: the hydrochloride, which dissolves easily and supplies the acid pH.
  • Stick pack mixed dry and made up by the consumer: either salt is workable, with the hydrochloride dissolving faster and the mononitrate easier to handle in the filling room.
  • Gummy or chew that goes through a cook: trial both salts in the real matrix, because pH and heat matter more than the label name.
  • An existing label and stability file: keep the salt already named and tested; changing it means a new specification and fresh stability work.

The product hub has the mononitrate specification and pack; the grades page sets this choice beside the physical forms; the stability page follows the matrix effects; the identity page proves the nitrate salt; the hydrochloride product page is the other salt; the methods library covers the tests; the quality page describes release.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation