02.1 Chloride vs bitartrate

Choline chloride vs choline bitartrate: choline content, water and the label

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-20 · Choline Chloride

On this page
  1. The choline content, and the weight it implies
  2. Water, pH and the chloride load
  3. What the label has to say
  4. The two specification sheets
  5. What a salt switch moves
  6. When to choose which

Choline chloride and choline bitartrate deliver the same nutrient from different salts. One gram of choline chloride carries about 746 mg of choline; one gram of choline bitartrate carries about 411 mg, so the chloride supplies the same choline from about 55% of the weight. The chloride is also deliquescent, close to neutral in solution and 25.4% chloride by mass, while the bitartrate is a crystalline acid salt. The choice changes the weigh-up, the water budget and the label line.

In one line

Per gram the chloride delivers about 1.8 times the choline of the bitartrate, but it brings 25.4% chloride and a deliquescence problem that the bitartrate does not have.

The choline content, and the weight it implies

The arithmetic is fixed by the formulas. Choline chloride is C5H14ClNO at 139.62 g/mol; the choline cation is 104.17 g/mol, so the theoretical fraction is 74.6%. Choline bitartrate is C9H19NO7 at 253.25 g/mol, so its theoretical fraction is 41.1%, and the catalog window is 40.5–41.5% by HPLC. The catalog here does not fix a choline window for the chloride; the measured figure comes from the lot certificate.

For the same choline, divide by the fraction: 82.5 mg of choline needs about 111 mg of chloride or 201 mg of bitartrate; 300 mg needs about 402 mg or 730 mg; 550 mg needs about 737 mg or 1,338 mg. The ratio is about 1.82 at every dose, because it is a ratio of molecular weights.

Salt weight for a target choline figure · theoretical fractions
CholineCholine chlorideCholine bitartrate
82.5 mg≈111 mg≈201 mg
100 mg≈134 mg≈243 mg
300 mg≈402 mg≈730 mg
550 mg≈737 mg≈1,338 mg

Use the measured choline from the certificate for the label worksheet, not the theoretical fraction: a lot at 99.0% assay carries about 73.9% choline.

Water, pH and the chloride load

Both salts are hygroscopic; the chloride is deliquescent. It can take up enough water from the air to become sticky or wet, which is why it is often supplied as a solution and why the powder needs a sealed foil pack and a dry filling room. The bitartrate also picks up water and has a loss-on-drying limit of ≤1.0%, but it does not usually collapse into a liquid phase. The pack requirement is therefore stricter for the chloride, and the in-use period after opening is shorter.

The two solutions sit in different pH ranges. The chloride is 6.0–8.0 in 10% solution; the bitartrate is 3.0–4.5 in 5% solution because of the hydrogen tartrate. In a carbonate or bicarbonate system the bitartrate reacts and can release carbon dioxide, while the chloride is the easier fit. In a capsule or stick where acidity is unwanted, the chloride avoids the acid note but brings the water problem.

The chloride also adds mass that is not choline. One gram of the salt carries about 254 mg of chloride, and 737 mg of the salt — the amount that supplies 550 mg of choline — carries about 187 mg of chloride. That is a nutrient in its own right, and it should be counted if the formula declares chloride or if the taste and the salt load matter. The bitartrate carries tartrate instead, which is acidic and contributes to the taste.

What the label has to say

The ingredient line names the salt and the nutrient line names choline: “Choline (as choline chloride)” or “Choline (as choline bitartrate)”. The salt on the label must match the certificate. If the panel declares choline, the number is choline, not salt; the salt weight behind 100 mg of choline is about 134 mg of chloride or 243 mg of bitartrate.

In the EU, Annex XIII of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 sets a nutrient reference value of 82.5 mg for choline. That is 100% of the NRV, so 100 mg of choline is about 121%, and the salt weight that supplies it is about 134 mg of chloride. The three permitted choline claims in Regulation (EC) No 432/2012 also use 82.5 mg of choline per 100 g, per 100 ml or per portion as the threshold. The claim is about choline, not about the salt, and the current wording should be checked before printing.

In the United States, the Daily Value is 550 mg for adults and children aged four and over, so 100 mg of choline is 18% of the Daily Value. The Supplement Facts panel declares choline and names the source. The salt weight is not the choline figure; presenting it as choline overstates the nutrient by about a third.

The two specification sheets

Catalog specification · choline chloride against choline bitartrate
LineCholine chlorideCholine bitartrate
CAS · formula · molecular weight67-48-1 · C5H14ClNO · 139.6287-67-2 · C9H19NO7 · 253.25
Salt assay98.0–101.0% by titration96.5–100.5% as-is by titration
CholineReported on the COA; 74.6% theoretical40.5–41.5% by HPLC
Loss on drying≤1.0%≤1.0%
pH6.0–8.0 in 10% solution3.0–4.5 in 5% solution
Particle size≥95% through 80 mesh≥95% through 40 mesh
Assay methodTitration; name the ion and titrantTitration of choline, calculated as bitartrate

The two sheets are not interchangeable: the method, the basis, the mesh and the label all move with the salt. A specification written for one salt has to be rewritten for the other.

What a salt switch moves

A salt switch · the lines to recheck
ChangeChloride to bitartrateBitartrate to chloride
Weight for the same choline×1.82×0.55
Capsule or fillLarger fill, or a lower doseSmaller fill, or a higher dose
pH and tasteMore acidic, tartLess acidic, saline
Water pick-upLower, still hygroscopicHigher, deliquescent
Label and stability fileNew salt name and choline figureNew salt name and choline figure

A switch is a formulation change, not a purchasing substitution. The weigh-up, the fill weight, the water budget, the assay method, the label and the stability file all move. A 500 mg fill of bitartrate is a 206 mg choline dose; the same fill of chloride is 373 mg, a different dose.

When to choose which

Choose the chloride for a liquid or a syrup, where the near-neutral pH and the higher choline per gram reduce the dose weight and the water is already in the formula. Choose it for a dry blend only when the pack and the room can exclude water. Choose the bitartrate for a dry capsule or tablet where the acidic, crystalline powder has already been validated and the label names the bitartrate.

If the label says choline bitartrate, only the bitartrate will do; if the label says choline chloride, only the chloride. The nutrient is the same, but the salt is part of the identity, the dose arithmetic and the regulatory file.

The catalog values are on the choline chloride product page and the choline bitartrate product page. The grade comparison is on the grades page, the release panel on the COA page, the assays in the methods library, and the release workflow on the quality page.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation