How to prove a lot is calcium HMB
A calcium HMB lot is the calcium salt only when four checks agree. The paperwork must give the form and the CAS number; HPLC with infrared must identify the acid; calcium must match the stoichiometry; assay and loss on drying must account for the whole mass. No single line does that work. The calcium figure is the one most certificates print without the arithmetic behind it.
Identity is proved by agreement: HPLC and infrared name the acid, calcium names the salt, and the moisture figure closes the mass balance.
Four questions, four kinds of evidence
A datasheet can name the right material and still say nothing about the powder in the drum. The rows below are separate questions, and each needs its own measurement. Most disputes start because only the first row was answered.
| Layer | Question | Measurement | What it establishes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paperwork | Which form is claimed? | Name, CAS number, formula | Nothing about the powder itself |
| Chromatography and infrared | Is the acid HMB? | HPLC retention time; IR bands | The molecule, not its salt |
| Calcium | Is the counter-ion calcium? | Complexometric titration or ICP-OES | The salt form |
| Mass balance | Is the powder diluted or wet? | Assay, loss on drying, ash | Whether one material explains all the numbers |
The calcium ratio: proving the salt
One calcium ion balances two HMB molecules. In the anhydrous salt, C10H18CaO6, calcium is 14.6% by mass, and the mass ratio of HMB to calcium is 236.26 to 40.08, or about 5.9 to 1. Both figures follow from the formula, so either can be turned into a check on a certificate.
The first consequence concerns the assay reference. The acid cannot exceed 86.1% of the salt's mass, so a figure of 98.0–102.0% can only be expressed as calcium HMB. A certificate that prints “HMB 99%” and leaves the reference open has produced an ambiguous number, and comparing it with another supplier's figure is meaningless until the reference is fixed.
The second consequence concerns a low calcium result. The catalog window is 12.0–14.0%, and its top is close to theory. At its bottom the figure is 2.6 points under the stoichiometric value. Water inside the 5.0% loss-on-drying limit accounts for at most about 0.7 of a point, so moisture alone does not explain the gap. What remains points to a free-acid fraction, a carrier, a hydrated form or a different calcium stoichiometry, and calcium plus loss on drying plus ash is what tells those apart.
A blend of salt and free acid is the case the assay misses. The HPLC measures the acid from both components, so the total can be built to sit inside the range while calcium falls in proportion to the free-acid share. Calcium sees the counter-ion, which is why it belongs in the identity file even where the specification lists it as an assay line.
Diffraction and the solid state
Diffraction looks at the crystal, not at the percentage. A diffractogram records the crystalline phases present and compares their spacing with a reference pattern, so it can separate the anhydrous salt from a hydrate, and either from an amorphous carrier used to dilute a powder. It measures neither purity nor the counter-ion; it identifies the solid form.
Before accepting a “match” statement, ask which reference pattern was used and what the detection limit is. On a disputed lot, diffraction alongside calcium, HPLC and infrared is worth more than any of them alone, because each answers a different row of the table above. Diffraction is not a release test here, and a certificate that says only “XRD conforms” without the pattern has told the buyer almost nothing.
What substitution looks like
| Substitute | What changes | Signal | Test |
|---|---|---|---|
| HMB free acid | Calcium absent; acidic liquid or an adsorbed powder | Calcium low; pH low; poor flow | Calcium, pH, appearance |
| Leucine | Low-cost amino acid with a similar name | Nitrogen present where HMB has none | Nitrogen determination, HPLC |
| Carrier diluent | Active mass reduced | Assay low, calcium low, ash or moisture shifted | Mass balance, calcium |
| Another calcium salt | Calcium without HMB | Calcium high against the assay | HPLC and infrared, calcium |
| Moisture | Loss on drying raised | As-is assay low; dried-basis assay normal | Loss on drying |
Appearance is the weakest signal of the set. White to off-white covers a wide range, and a blend can be milled to look the same. The strong signals are calcium, nitrogen and the mass balance. A certificate that gives appearance and assay but no identity line has left the most likely substitution untested.
Identity clauses for the specification
- “Calcium β-hydroxy-β-methylbutyrate, CAS 135236-72-5, C10H18CaO6.”
- “Assay 98.0–102.0% by HPLC, expressed as calcium HMB, with the basis stated.”
- “Calcium 12.0–14.0% by complexometric titration; report the method.”
- “Identification by HPLC retention and infrared spectrum; report the reference used.”
- “Loss on drying ≤5.0%; particle size ≥95% through 80 mesh.”
- “No free acid or diluent above the agreed limit; no nitrogen above the method limit.”
Two clauses carry the identity work: the assay reference and the calcium method. Take them out and a certificate can still be internally consistent without ever describing a salt.
Questions to put to the supplier
- What form is this lot, and what CAS number does the certificate carry?
- Does the assay refer to HMB or to calcium HMB, and on what basis is it calculated?
- What is the calcium figure, by which method, and what loss on drying sits beside it?
- Will you send the HPLC chromatogram with the detector named, and the infrared spectrum?
- On a disputed lot, will you join a re-test of the retained sample?
Answered directly, those five give a buyer an identity file; an assay percentage alone does not. Catalog values are on the product hub, each figure is placed on the COA page, the grades page sets the salt against the free acid, the diffraction note explains the solid-state test, and the quality page describes the release file.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation