Calcium HMB and HMB free acid: choosing the form
HMB is sold as the calcium salt, a white powder, or as the free acid, a pale yellow liquid. The salt is the form used in capsules, tablets and stick packs; the free acid puts more HMB into every gram and suits ready-to-drink formats. The two forms do not share a CAS number, a molecular weight or a label declaration, so the form has to be fixed before the specification is written.
The calcium salt and the free acid carry different CAS numbers, different HMB mass per gram and different label names, so the form is a specification decision before it is a formulation one.
Why HMB is offered in two forms
HMB is 3-hydroxy-3-methylbutyric acid, a small branched-chain hydroxy acid. Its single carboxyl group can stay protonated, which gives the free acid, or it can be neutralised by calcium, which gives a salt with two acid molecules for each calcium ion. That is the whole difference, and it is enough to produce two products with separate identities.
Suppliers sell the calcium salt as the supplement form because it is a stable, free-flowing solid that can be weighed, blended and filled on ordinary equipment. The free acid is a liquid at room temperature, which makes it convenient for a beverage line and awkward for a capsule line. Neither form is a diluted or coated version of the other; a purchase order that says only “HMB” has not specified either.
The two forms side by side
| Property | Calcium HMB | HMB free acid |
|---|---|---|
| CAS number | 135236-72-5 | 625-08-1 |
| Formula | C10H18CaO6 | C5H10O3 |
| Molecular weight | 274.32 (anhydrous) | 118.13 |
| Appearance | White to off-white powder | Colourless to pale yellow liquid |
| HMB per gram | About 0.81–0.86 g | 1.00 g |
| Calcium | 12.0–14.0% by titration | None |
| Typical dosage form | Capsule, tablet, stick pack | Ready-to-drink, liquid concentrate |
| Label name | Calcium β-hydroxy-β-methylbutyrate | β-Hydroxy-β-methylbutyric acid |
The mass difference is the commercial consequence. Every gram of calcium salt carries the calcium, so a formula written around a gram of HMB needs more salt than free acid. The next two sections work through the arithmetic and the handling.
Solubility, flow and handling
The salt dissolves in water to give a clear solution, and that is why it works in stick packs and drink mixes. It is also hygroscopic: an open pouch takes up moisture, the powder cakes and the loss on drying climbs. The catalog specification therefore pairs the 80 mesh particle size with a loss on drying limit of 5.0%, and the pack has to be closed between weighings. A granulated grade is available on request when a line needs better flow and less dust.
The free acid is a liquid that mixes with water and ethanol, and its solutions are acidic. That acidity has to be buffered in a ready-to-drink formula, and the buffer has to be checked against the calcium in any other ingredient. The free acid is normally dispensed by weight or volume into the aqueous phase; it is not a powder that can be scooped into a capsule.
Solubility is not the same as stability. The salt solution is close to neutral and can cloud when it meets phosphate or citrate salts, because calcium phosphate and calcium citrate are much less soluble than calcium HMB. The free acid solution has a different pH and a different set of interactions, so a formula cannot be moved from one form to the other without checking the look of the solution, its pH and the hold time.
Dose arithmetic and the label
The conversion follows the molecular weights. The anhydrous salt is 274.32 g/mol and carries two HMB molecules at 118.13 g/mol each, so 236.26 ÷ 274.32 gives 86.1% HMB by mass; the monohydrate, at 292.34 g/mol, gives 80.8%. A label that declares 3 g of calcium HMB is therefore declaring about 2.5 g of HMB, and the same 2.5 g from the free acid weighs 2.5 g. The 3 g figure is the quantity used in published research on the calcium salt, not a recommendation for a finished product.
The salt also puts calcium on the label. At 12.0–14.0% calcium, a 3 g serving carries 360–420 mg of the mineral, which is a material fraction of the daily reference intake in both the EU and the US. That calcium line belongs in the nutrition declaration, and it is one reason the two forms are not label-equivalent even when the HMB figure is matched.
Declare the form as well as the quantity. “HMB 2.5 g” does not say whether the panel means the acid or the salt, and a reader cannot convert it without the form. The certificate, the specification and the panel should use the same name and the same basis.
What to write into the specification
- “Calcium β-hydroxy-β-methylbutyrate, CAS 135236-72-5, C10H18CaO6.”
- “Assay 98.0–102.0% by HPLC, with the assay reference and the basis stated.”
- “Calcium 12.0–14.0% by complexometric titration; report the method.”
- “Loss on drying ≤5.0%; particle size ≥95% through 80 mesh.”
- “Heavy metals and microbiology as listed on the specification.”
- “Destination market and dosage form confirmed before the order.”
We supply the calcium salt. The free acid is a separate purchase with its own specification, pack and label, and it should not be substituted without written change control. The product hub carries the catalog values; the level-four comparison sets HMB against creatine monohydrate; the compliance page covers the market route; the methods section explains the assays; the quality page describes release.
When a form is the wrong choice
If the dosage form is a capsule or a dry stick, the free acid is the wrong starting point: it is a liquid, and adsorbing it onto a carrier produces a different specification with a different assay and a different label. If the formula is a clear ready-to-drink and the calcium load is already high, the salt may add more mineral than the label wants, and the free acid becomes the practical option.
The market file can also decide. A buyer who has cleared the calcium salt for a market should not assume the free acid inherits that clearance, because the two are separate entries with separate names. The reverse is equally true, and a form switch in either direction needs a new specification, a new label check and a written change control.
In this document
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation