5-HTP vs L-tryptophan: form, dose and the label
5-HTP and L-tryptophan are different molecules, different CAS numbers and different label ingredients. 5-HTP carries an extra oxygen on the indole ring — C11H12N2O3, CAS 56-69-9 — and L-tryptophan does not: C11H12N2O2, CAS 73-22-3. A 98% assay on either material says nothing about which one is in the drum, and one cannot be substituted for the other on a label.
5-HTP and L-tryptophan are different label ingredients; the assay percentage does not make one a substitute for the other.
Two indole amino acids, one oxygen apart
| Property | 5-HTP | L-tryptophan |
|---|---|---|
| CAS | 56-69-9 | 73-22-3 |
| Formula | C11H12N2O3 | C11H12N2O2 |
| Molar mass | 220.23 g/mol | 204.23 g/mol |
| Label name | 5-HTP or 5-hydroxytryptophan | L-tryptophan |
| Catalog assay | 98.0–101.0% dried basis, HPLC | 98.5–101.5% dried basis, HPLC |
| Identity tests | IR and UV | IR and ninhydrin; specific rotation |
| Principal source | Griffonia seed extract or synthesis | Fermentation or synthesis |
Both are indole amino acids and both are white to off-white crystalline powders, which is why appearance proves nothing. 5-HTP is hydroxylated at the 5-position of the indole ring; tryptophan is not. 5-HTP is not a grade of tryptophan and tryptophan is not a grade of 5-HTP.
The names carry the confusion. 5-HTP is the abbreviation for 5-hydroxytryptophan; oxitriptan is the international nonproprietary name used in medicine files. L-tryptophan is the protein amino acid, and “tryptophan” without a prefix is ambiguous because DL-tryptophan also exists. A purchase order that says “tryptophan” has not named a material.
The mass conversion is arithmetic, not equivalence
The molar masses differ by 16 g/mol, one oxygen: 220.23 against 204.23. That gives a mass ratio of 1.078, so 100 mg of 5-HTP contains the same number of molecules as about 92.7 mg of tryptophan. The arithmetic is exact and it is not a dose equivalence. The two are different ingredients with different specifications, different stability and different regulatory routes; a formula cannot swap one for the other by applying a factor.
On the label, the amount is the mass of the named ingredient. A 100 mg 5-HTP capsule declares 100 mg of 5-HTP, not 92.7 mg of tryptophan, and a 500 mg tryptophan capsule declares tryptophan. No conversion factor belongs on the panel. The factor is useful in a laboratory calculation and does not belong in a formulation discussion.
The reverse factor, 204.23 ÷ 220.23 = 0.927, is just as exact and just as unusable on a label. It can help a laboratory compare molar concentrations; it cannot turn a 5-HTP specification into a tryptophan specification, and it does not adjust for the different assay ranges, 98.0–101.0% against 98.5–101.5%.
Regulation follows the ingredient, not the family
In the EU, L-tryptophan is an amino acid sold under general food law and national supplement rules; 5-HTP is not a vitamin or mineral and its route depends on the member state, with a novel-food question that follows the source. In the US, both can be dietary ingredients, but 5-HTP carries the pre-1994 or new-ingredient question for the specific material. In the UK, retained food law applies, with Northern Ireland following the EU rules.
A permission for one is not a permission for the other. The 5-HTP compliance page sets out the four checks; the L-tryptophan compliance page does the same for the amino acid.
What the label has to say
EU labelling names the ingredient as used: “5-HTP” or “5-hydroxytryptophan” for the isolated material, “Griffonia simplicifolia seed extract” for the extract, with the standardisation stated. “Tryptophan” is not a synonym and cannot stand in for 5-HTP. In the US, the Supplement Facts panel declares the dietary ingredient and the ingredient list names the source; in the UK the same naming principle applies under retained law.
If the product is an extract, the label should say so; if it is synthetic, the label should not imply the plant. A “natural” statement is a marketing statement, not a source declaration.
When to choose which
| Brief | Material | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Existing product labelled L-tryptophan | L-tryptophan | The label names the amino acid, not 5-HTP |
| New product named for 5-HTP | 5-HTP | The label and the specification must match |
| Label wants a Griffonia source | Griffonia extract | Synthetic material does not support the name |
| Consistent colour and flow wanted | Synthetic 5-HTP | No plant matrix or harvest variation |
| Market restricts 5-HTP | L-tryptophan, if permitted | The restriction follows the ingredient |
| Analytical comparison | Both, each with a certificate | Without identity data the comparison is undefined |
Choose by the label, the market and the source documents. The assay percentage is the last question, not the first.
The commercial question is usually framed as a swap, but the file records it as a new material. The label, the market notification, the certificate and the stability data all follow the ingredient name. A buyer who changes the name on the artwork before changing the specification has created a mismatch that no certificate can close.
What changes when you switch
Switching from one to the other changes the label name, the specification, the identity tests, the stability data and the regulatory file. It does not change the assay range: both can sit near 98–101%, which is exactly why the switch is easy to underestimate. Run the new material through the same qualification as a new source, even when the certificate looks familiar.
The 5-HTP range is on the product page; the source choice is on the source page; the certificate lines are on the COA page; the L-tryptophan range is on the L-tryptophan page; the assay definition is in the assay note.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation