02 Source comparison

Griffonia extract or synthetic 5-HTP: choosing a source

Technical document 02 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · 5-HTP

On this page
  1. Two routes to the same molecule
  2. What changes on the certificate
  3. Colour, flow and the 40 mesh line
  4. What the dosage form needs
  5. What to write into the specification
  6. When neither source fits

5-HTP reaches the drum by two routes: extraction from the seed of Griffonia simplicifolia or chemical synthesis. Both routes can be sold at 98.0–101.0% on the dried basis, so the assay does not choose between them. The impurity profile, the source documents, the regulatory route and the label do.

In one line

The source decides the impurity profile, the documents and the label; the assay percentage does not.

Two routes to the same molecule

Griffonia simplicifolia is a West African shrub; the seed carries 5-HTP, and an extract is purified and standardised to the 98% range. The extract route carries a plant matrix through part of the process, so the certificate has to describe the extraction solvent, the carrier if one is used, the extract ratio and the pesticide panel alongside the assay. A Griffonia extract that is 98% 5-HTP is still an extract, and the source documents are part of the material.

The synthetic route builds the molecule from defined starting materials and purifies the crystal. It has no harvest and no plant matrix, but it has route-specific intermediates, solvents and a stereochemical step. The certificate has to describe those instead. Neither route is automatically cleaner: a well-controlled extract and a well-controlled synthetic lot can both meet the same assay, and a poorly controlled lot on either route can miss the related-substance profile.

The two materials share CAS 56-69-9 and C11H12N2O3. The difference is the supply chain and the paperwork, not the molecular formula.

What changes on the certificate

Griffonia extract and synthetic 5-HTP, line by line
DimensionGriffonia extractSynthetic
Source recordPlant, seed, harvest and extractorStarting materials, route and manufacturer
Assay98.0–101.0% dried basis98.0–101.0% dried basis
Related substancesPlant indoles and purification residuesRoute intermediates and stereochemical impurities
ResiduesPesticides, extraction solvent, carrierRoute solvents and reagents
Colour and odourCan carry a faint plant noteUsually neutral
Regulatory fileExtract-specific source questionIsolated-substance source question
Label nameGriffonia seed extract, standardised5-HTP or 5-hydroxytryptophan

Read the table as a set of questions, not a ranking. The extract route carries a pesticide and plant-matrix question; the synthetic route carries a solvent and route-intermediate question. Both carry the same metal, micro and drying lines.

Colour, flow and the 40 mesh line

Both routes target an off-white to pale cream crystalline powder at ≥95% through 40 mesh, but the two powders do not behave identically in a hopper. An extract can carry a faint colour or odour that the synthetic crystal does not, and the crystal habit can differ enough to change flow. The catalog sheet does not fix bulk density; if the capsule fill depends on it, ask for the figure on the lot.

Milling is a specification line because it changes flow, blending and dissolution. A 40 mesh powder and a granulated powder can be the same chemistry and different process inputs. Granulation and dilution are available on request, and a declared dilution is a format, not an adulteration; an undeclared one is a different problem.

What the dosage form needs

A capsule or tablet needs flow, a low loss on drying and a particle size that blends evenly. A stick pack or drink mix adds water: 5-HTP is sparingly soluble in water and soluble in dilute acid, so the formula's pH and water activity matter more than the assay percentage. The source also changes the colour and taste of the finished powder, which can matter in a clear sachet.

When the source changes, the fill weight may not. Both routes are specified at 98.0–101.0%, so the 5-HTP mass per capsule is set by the assay and the fill, not by the source. What changes is the validation: a new source is a new supplier, a new impurity profile and usually a new stability data set. Switching source also changes the label name, the source declaration, the impurity panel and the validation file; the assay may not move at all.

What to write into the specification

The specification should name the source in the material line, not in a note. “5-HTP (Griffonia simplicifolia seed extract), 98.0–101.0% on the dried basis, CAS 56-69-9” and “5-HTP (synthetic), 98.0–101.0% on the dried basis, CAS 56-69-9” are two different specifications with two different document sets.

  • Assay by HPLC, 98.0–101.0% on the dried basis.
  • Identification by IR and UV; loss on drying ≤0.5%; residue on ignition ≤0.1%.
  • Related substances: individual and total limits, method and quantification limit.
  • Heavy metals Pb ≤3 · As ≤2 · Cd ≤1 · Hg ≤0.1 mg/kg; the micro panel.
  • Particle size ≥95% through 40 mesh; pack and storage statement.
  • Source-specific lines: extraction solvent, carrier and pesticide panel for the extract; route, solvents and stereochemistry for the synthetic material.

When neither source fits

If the destination market does not permit 5-HTP, the source does not fix it. If the label promises Griffonia and the drum is synthetic, the mismatch is a labelling defect before it is a quality one. If the formula needs a diluted premix, that is a dilution format, not a third source. And if the brief is for tryptophan, 5-HTP is not a substitute; the two are different label ingredients.

The catalog range and the pack are on the product page; the certificate lines are on the COA page; the market question is on the compliance page; the difference from tryptophan is on the comparison page.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation