02.1 Peanut vs soy

Peanut peptides vs soy peptides: two legumes, two labels

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · Peanut Protein Peptides

On this page
  1. Two legumes, one hydrolysis logic
  2. The specifications side by side
  3. The amino acid profile and the protein claim
  4. The allergen is the decisive difference
  5. Taste, colour and the matrix
  6. What changes when you switch
  7. How to choose between them

Peanut and soy peptides are both legume-derived hydrolysates, sold on a protein minimum and a peptide minimum. They are not interchangeable: the catalog grades differ, the amino acid profiles differ, the allergens are different proteins, and the taste and colour are different. A switch changes the label, the allergen control plan and the formula, not only the ingredient name.

In one line

Peanut and soy peptides are both legume hydrolysates, but the protein level, the amino acid profile, the allergen and the taste differ, so one is not a drop-in for the other.

Two legumes, one hydrolysis logic

Both typically start from a legume protein, are extracted at alkaline pH and precipitated at the isoelectric point, then hydrolysed with a food-grade protease, inactivated, clarified and dried. Both are sold as peptide powders with protein, peptide, ash, moisture and mesh lines, and both can be bitter at a high degree of hydrolysis.

The similarity is the process, not the ingredient. The protein source sets the amino acid profile, the allergen and the taste, and those are the differences that decide the application.

The specifications side by side

Peanut protein peptides against soy protein peptides, catalog grades
PropertyPeanut peptidesSoy peptides
SourcePeanutSoy
Protein≥80.0% by Kjeldahl≥90.0% by Kjeldahl
Peptide≥70.0% by HPLC≥80.0% by HPLC
Ash≤5.0%≤5.0%
AllergenPeanutSoy
Allergen statusMajor allergen in the EU and the USMajor allergen in the EU and the US
Typical label namePeanut protein peptidesSoy protein peptides
Amino acid noteLower in lysine than soyHigher in lysine; sulfur amino acids limiting
Sensory noteNutty, roasted; can be bitterBeany, green; can be bitter

The table compares catalog specifications, not rank. The soy grade carries more protein and peptide per gram; the peanut grade carries its own sensory profile and its own allergen. Neither figure tells you which is the better fit for a formula.

The amino acid profile and the protein claim

Soy protein is a complete protein, and soy protein isolate is commonly cited at PDCAAS 1.0. Peanut protein scores lower; it is lower in lysine than soy, and its amino acid profile does not match the soy isolate. Hydrolysis changes the peptide size, not the amino acid composition, so a peanut peptide does not become a complete protein by being hydrolysed.

The protein claim is calculated on the finished product. In the EU, “source of protein” is 12% of the energy from protein and “high protein” is 20%; in the US, “good source” is 10% of the daily value and “excellent source” is 20%. The peptide figure is not a protein-quality measure, and it is not a claim.

The arithmetic also changes. A 10 g serving of peanut peptide at 80% protein carries about 8 g protein; 10 g of soy peptide at 90% carries about 9 g. To deliver 8 g protein from the soy grade, use about 8.9 g. A 1:1 swap by weight is not a 1:1 swap by protein.

The allergen is the decisive difference

Both are major allergens, but they are different proteins. Peanut allergens include Ara h 1, Ara h 2 and Ara h 3; soy allergens include Gly m 4, Gly m 5 and Gly m 6. A peanut-allergic consumer is not necessarily soy-allergic, and the reverse is also true; the two declarations are separate.

Peanut allergy is common and often persistent; soy allergy is less common and often outgrown. Hydrolysis reduces some of the proteins, but it does not remove the declaration. “Hypoallergenic” and “allergen-free” are not available for either ingredient, and a negative ELISA does not prove absence.

For a manufacturer, the switch is an allergen change. Adding peanut to a line that has run soy adds a new major allergen, with its own cleaning validation, dedicated tools, label and “may contain” assessment. The EU Annex II list and the US FALCPA list both name peanut and soy, so the label names the source, not the peptide.

Taste, colour and the matrix

Peanut peptides carry nutty and roasted notes; soy peptides carry beany and green notes. Both can be bitter at a high degree of hydrolysis, and both can brown in a warm, moist matrix. The peanut grade is off-white to light tan; the soy grade has its own colour range, and the two are not visually identical.

The matrix decides how much the taste matters. A capsule hides it; a powder blend or a drink does not. Masking with flavour, sweetness or pH can help, but it does not change the allergen or the protein figure. Taste is a formulation variable, not a grade defect.

Clarity in a beverage is a separate test. Peanut peptides are soluble and give a clear to slightly turbid solution; the soy grade has its own solubility and turbidity, and a clear drink may need a trial with both.

What changes when you switch

A switch changes the label name, the allergen statement, the protein and peptide numbers, the dose, the taste and the supplier documents. It also changes the cleaning and changeover plan, because the allergen is new to the line.

Do not swap on the protein figure alone. Match the protein and peptide delivered per serving, then check the amino acid profile, the allergen and the taste. If the market file covers soy peptides but not peanut peptides, the switch is a regulatory change too, and the buyer's regulatory team confirms the route.

Run a bench trial in the finished matrix before the production order. Check the colour, the taste, the clarity, the fill weight and the label. A supplier's certificate does not answer a matrix question.

How to choose between them

Choose peanut when the brief calls for peanut, the allergen is acceptable, the sensory profile fits and the 80/70 grade is enough. Choose soy when the formula needs more protein and peptide per gram, a more neutral taste and an established supply, and the soy allergen is manageable.

If neither allergen fits, a third legume protein is a different decision, not a drop-in. Pea protein isolate has its own protein level and taste; it is not an allergen-free promise. Compare the specification, not the marketing name.

The peanut product hub and the soy isolate page carry the catalog specifications; the grades page covers the peanut axes; the compliance page covers the allergen file; the methods section describes the assays; the quality page describes the release workflow.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation