06 Identity & adulteration

How we prove a zinc citrate lot is the citrate

Technical document 06 · Reviewed 2026-11-18 · Zinc Citrate

On this page
  1. The four identity questions
  2. The 3:2 ratio and the water
  3. XRD, IR and the phase question
  4. The routes worth testing
  5. How to write the specification
  6. Five questions for a supplier

A zinc citrate lot is the citrate only when four things agree: the zinc assay, the citrate identity, the 3:2 zinc-to-citrate stoichiometry with two waters of crystallisation, and a disclosure that nothing else is in the drum. The EDTA titration answers the first; the citrate reaction and infrared spectrum answer the second; loss on drying and the ratio close the third; the specification and the supplier's answers close the fourth.

In one line

A zinc assay is not an identity: the citrate test, the 3:2 ratio, the hydrate water and the disclosure must all point to one lot.

The four identity questions

Layer one is the metal. EDTA titration at about pH 10 measures total zinc in the portion that dissolved, with Eriochrome Black T as the usual indicator; it is a quantity, not an identity.

Layer two is the anion. A citrate reaction gives a positive response for citrate, and an infrared spectrum is compared with a reference for the carboxylate and hydroxyl bands. Neither is a purity assay: a blend can pass both while carrying a second zinc source.

Layer three is the stoichiometry and the water. Three divalent zinc ions balance two trivalent citrate ions, and the dihydrate carries two waters in the lattice; the ratio and the loss on drying tie the metal to the anion and the solid to its hydrate.

Layer four is disclosure. The drum should hold the citrate salt and nothing the paperwork omits: no zinc oxide to lift the assay, no zinc gluconate to change solubility, no citric acid to lift the citrate signal, and no carrier that dilutes both. One result can close one layer and leave the others open.

The 3:2 ratio and the water

Zinc citrate is Zn3(C6H5O7)2·2H2O, about 610 g/mol, roughly 32% zinc, 62% citrate and 5.9% water by mass. The 3:2 ratio is fixed by charge balance: zinc is divalent, citrate is trivalent, and a different ratio needs another ion or a different anion.

If a certificate reports a quantitative citrate result, convert both to moles and check for three zinc to two citrate. The standard release panel does not include that assay; identity is by reaction and infrared, so the ratio is an extra test for a disputed lot or a new source. High citrate against zinc points to added citric acid; high zinc against citrate points to a second zinc source. Read both on the same basis.

Two waters are about 5.9% of the dihydrate, and the loss-on-drying limit is ≤6.0%. That is a tight ceiling, and a lot near it has little room for surface moisture. The anhydrous salt has no lattice water, a lower loss on drying and more zinc per gram. Karl Fischer is the direct water test when the hydrate is disputed.

XRD, IR and the phase question

X-ray diffraction identifies crystalline phases. Here it detects crystalline zinc oxide and checks the hydrate phase against the declaration. The result depends on the detection limit, so a report that says “no crystalline zinc oxide detected” without a limit does not answer the question.

Infrared spectroscopy works at the bond level. Carboxylate bands, the hydroxyl region and the water band form a fingerprint against a reference. It is fast and not quantitative: a blend can show citrate features while the drum also holds an oxide. XRD and IR are complementary, and neither replaces the assay or the moisture result.

XRD is not on the standard release panel. Order it for a suspected second zinc source, a new supplier, or a form claim the certificate does not prove, and ask for the detection limit and the sample preparation.

The routes worth testing

Adulteration and substitution routes · what moves and what detects them
RouteWhat movesTest that exposes it
Zinc oxide additionZinc rises, citrate share falls, pH moves alkalineXRD for crystalline oxide; citrate ratio; pH
Zinc gluconate substitution or blendZinc falls, solubility and taste changeCitrate reaction and IR; quantitative citrate
Citric acid additionCitrate rises against zinc, pH fallsCitrate assay; pH; ratio calculation
Anhydrous sold as dihydrateZinc per gram rises, loss on drying fallsLoss on drying or Karl Fischer; hydrate declaration

Zinc oxide is the most direct route because it carries about 80% zinc. A small addition lifts the assay and dilutes the citrate, and the powder can still look white and flow. The zinc figure alone will not catch it; the ratio, the pH and an XRD screen will. Zinc gluconate works the other way: at about 14% zinc it lowers the assay, so it appears as a blend or a mislabelled lot. It changes solubility and taste, and citrate identity separates it from the citrate salt.

Citric acid is the opposite of an extender: it raises citrate while lowering zinc and pH. A citrate result high against zinc, with a pH below the 5.0–7.0 range, is the signature. A hydrate switch is not adulteration but a mislabelling risk: the anhydrous salt carries more zinc and a lower loss on drying, so a certificate that reports either without naming the hydrate leaves the buyer guessing.

How to write the specification

  • “Zinc citrate dihydrate, tri-zinc dicitrate, CAS 5990-32-9; hydrate named on the certificate.”
  • “Zinc 31.0–32.5% by complexometric EDTA on the dried basis; basis stated on the certificate.”
  • “Citrate identity by reaction and infrared spectrum against a named reference.”
  • “Loss on drying ≤6.0%; pH of 5% suspension 5.0–7.0.”
  • “≥95% through 40 mesh; bulk density 0.50–0.85 g/mL.”
  • “No added zinc oxide, zinc gluconate or citric acid; no undeclared carrier.”

The prohibitions carry as much weight as the positive limits. A zinc range alone does not exclude a second zinc source, and no supplier can be held to a restriction the specification never states. The hydrate line follows the same rule: “zinc citrate” alone describes a family, not a drum.

Five questions for a supplier

  1. Which hydrate is this lot, and which CAS number is on the certificate?
  2. What zinc result and basis belong to this lot, and what citrate identity method and reference were used?
  3. What is the loss on drying or Karl Fischer water, and does it match the two waters of the dihydrate?
  4. Is the lot a single salt, or a blend containing oxide, gluconate, citric acid or a carrier?
  5. Can you supply an XRD screen for crystalline zinc oxide, a quantitative citrate result, and the retained sample?

Five specific answers amount to a material you can write into a specification. One who answers only the zinc figure is quoting a number. The COA page shows where those answers appear on the certificate; the grade page covers the hydrate and salt choice; the XRD and FTIR notes describe the methods; the catalogue line is on the zinc citrate hub.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation