Anhydrous vs nonahydrate magnesium citrate: the water and the fill
Strip the water from magnesium citrate nonahydrate and the same lattice becomes the anhydrous grade. The dry salt has a molar mass near 451 g/mol and carries 16.2% magnesium; the nonahydrate is close to 613 g/mol and carries 11.9%. The catalogue reflects that gap with 14.5–16.4% magnesium and loss on drying ≤2.0% on one side, and 11.0–12.5% magnesium with 24.0–28.0% Karl Fischer water on the other. A fixed label dose therefore needs about a third more powder on the hydrate, and the capsule, tablet or stick has to be sized for it.
The water line and the magnesium line move together, so fill weight has to be calculated from the pair of limits rather than from a single magnesium figure.
Three numbers, one fill weight
The label dose is elemental magnesium. The powder mass is that dose divided by the magnesium fraction of the grade, and the water content sets the fraction. For planning, use the catalog window; for release, use the result for the lot in hand.
| Grade and assay | Magnesium used | Powder for 100 mg |
|---|---|---|
| Nonahydrate, low end | 11.0% | 909 mg |
| Nonahydrate, midpoint | 11.75% | 851 mg |
| Nonahydrate, high end | 12.5% | 800 mg |
| Anhydrous, low end | 14.5% | 690 mg |
| Anhydrous, high end | 16.4% | 610 mg |
The 109 mg spread between the two nonahydrate edges is a capsule size or a stick fill. A lot at 11.2% needs more powder than one at 12.2%, so the fill setting follows the certificate rather than the catalogue midpoint.
The water is composition, not contamination
The nine waters account for roughly 162 g of the 613 g molar mass, or 26.4%. Karl Fischer is the method because it measures water specifically. Loss on drying measures whatever leaves under the oven conditions, and on this grade that is mostly crystal water; a loss-on-drying limit of ≤2.0% is the anhydrous specification, not a tighter version of the nonahydrate's 24.0–28.0% water. A nonahydrate certificate showing ≤2.0% loss on drying is the anhydrous grade.
The water window is wide. Twenty-four percent and 28% are not the same powder, and the midpoint is only a planning figure. Ask for the lot's Karl Fischer result and use it. The two windows are not independent: removing water raises the magnesium on a mass basis, and adding water lowers it. Read the pair as one composition, not as two unrelated passes.
The fill weight in the dosage form
A capsule has a fixed volume. A 500 mg fill delivers about 59 mg of magnesium at 11.75% and about 77 mg at 15.45%, so a 100 mg claim needs 851 mg of the nonahydrate or 647 mg of the anhydrous salt. On the nonahydrate that may mean a larger capsule, a denser fill or two capsules; on the anhydrous grade one capsule is realistic. A tablet has the same constraint in a different shape: 851 mg of active powder plus excipients can push the tablet weight past what most consumers will swallow, while 647 mg leaves more room.
Sticks and sachets are more forgiving of mass, and the nonahydrate's 80 mesh powder disperses readily, which is why the hydrate is common in those formats. A gummy has room for mass too, but its water activity and taste decide more than the grade does. Bulk density is not in the catalog for this grade, yet the fill volume depends on it; ask for the lot figure. Granulation changes flow and density, not the magnesium fraction.
Overage cannot rescue a fill weight that does not fit; it is a label and stability choice, and the capsule volume remains the first constraint.
Which format fits which grade
| Format | Which grade fits | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Capsule | Anhydrous for a high dose in one capsule; nonahydrate needs volume | Fill weight, bulk density and capsule size |
| Tablet | Anhydrous for a 100 mg claim; nonahydrate at a lower dose | Tablet weight, hardness and excipients |
| Stick or sachet | Nonahydrate; mass is available and the powder disperses | Seal integrity and moisture barrier |
| Beverage | Nonahydrate; it dissolves and the citrate taste is manageable | pH, mineral load and hold time |
| Gummy | Nonahydrate; mass is available | Water activity, taste and process heat |
The table is a starting point, not a rule. The fill trial and the label decide. The anhydrous grade is more concentrated, not more active, and the nonahydrate is heavier, not weaker.
What the label and the specification must say
The label declares elemental magnesium: the EU uses mg plus a percentage of 375 mg, the US a percentage of the 420 mg Daily Value. If the label also declares the salt weight, the hydrate has to be named and the magnesium figure recalculated. A grade switch is a new label, a new specification and new stability data, not a purchasing substitution.
The purchase order should name the hydrate, the CAS number, the magnesium range, the water range and the mesh. “Magnesium citrate” without the hydrate is a family name, and a certificate that reports 11.9% magnesium against a 14.5–16.4% line is a different product, not a short delivery. The water line on the certificate is the proof that the grade ordered is the grade packed.
Choosing between the two grades
- Choose the anhydrous grade when the fill volume is fixed, the dose is high, or freight and storage volume matter.
- Choose the nonahydrate when mass is available, as in a stick, a beverage or a gummy, and when the finer 80 mesh dispersion is wanted.
- Compare the mass needed per dose, not the drum weight or the magnesium percentage on its own.
- Handle a grade change as a project: fresh specification, fresh water result, fresh stability work and fresh label sums.
The product hub carries the nonahydrate catalog line; the anhydrous product page carries the comparator; the grade comparison places both among the process variants; the COA page shows where the water is reported; the compliance page covers the label route; the quality page covers release.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation