Ferrous fumarate vs ferrous sulfate: iron, solubility and the fill
Ferrous fumarate and ferrous sulfate heptahydrate deliver the same iron in different packages. The fumarate is specified at 31.0–33.0% iron, the heptahydrate at 19.5–20.5%, so a 20 mg iron claim takes about 61–65 mg of fumarate or 98–103 mg of sulfate. The fumarate is practically insoluble in water and the sulfate is freely soluble, so the fill, the taste, the colour and the process change with the salt.
The fumarate carries about 33% iron and the sulfate heptahydrate about 20%, so the same claim needs roughly three-fifths of the mass; solubility and the label move with it.
Two ferrous salts, two iron figures
Both materials supply iron in the ferrous state, and that is where the similarity ends. Ferrous fumarate is the iron(II) salt of fumaric acid, an anhydrous crystalline solid with no water of crystallisation. Ferrous sulfate heptahydrate is the iron(II) salt of sulfuric acid with seven water molecules in the lattice, and those waters are about 45% of the mass.
| Property | Ferrous fumarate | Ferrous sulfate heptahydrate |
|---|---|---|
| Formula | C4H2FeO4 | FeSO4·7H2O |
| CAS number | 141-01-5 | 7782-63-0 |
| Molecular weight | 169.90 | 278.01 |
| Iron by formula | 32.87% | 20.09% |
| Iron specification | 31.0–33.0% | 19.5–20.5% |
| Water in the solid | None; anhydrous | About 45% as water of crystallisation |
| Appearance | Orange-red to reddish-brown powder | Pale blue-green crystalline solid |
| Solubility in water | Practically insoluble; soluble in dilute acids | Freely soluble; acidic solution |
The formula figures and the specification figures are close but not identical, because a specification allows for assay and measurement. Use the certificate in front of you for the weigh-up, not the midpoint of a table.
Solubility changes the dosage form
The fumarate does not dissolve in water to any useful extent. A capsule or a tablet can carry it as a solid, and a suspension can carry it as dispersed particles, but a clear aqueous drink cannot. In dilute acid it dissolves, which is why an acidic matrix and the stomach's acid are part of its behaviour. The dissolution step in a tablet is therefore a real formulation question: granulation, disintegrant and compression force all affect how quickly the particles break down.
The sulfate dissolves readily and gives an acidic solution. That makes it easy to incorporate into a liquid or a stick pack, and it also means the taste is acidic and metallic. The solution is pale green; on oxidation it turns yellow-brown, and the colour change is visible in a clear pack.
Solubility is a formulation property, not a dose. It does not settle how much iron is absorbed, and this page makes no claim about absorption, tolerance or any health effect. Those are clinical and regulatory questions for the finished product, not a reason to choose one salt on a technical page.
The fill arithmetic
The label states elemental iron while the formula weighs a salt, so the conversion is a division. Between these two salts the gap is large enough to change a capsule size.
| Iron claim | Ferrous fumarate at 31.0–33.0% | Ferrous sulfate at 19.5–20.5% |
|---|---|---|
| 14 mg | 42–45 mg | 68–72 mg |
| 18 mg | 55–58 mg | 88–92 mg |
| 20 mg | 61–65 mg | 98–103 mg |
| 30 mg | 91–97 mg | 146–154 mg |
At a fixed fill, the gap runs the other way. A 500 mg fill of ferrous fumarate carries 155–165 mg of iron; the same fill of the heptahydrate carries 98–103 mg. For a product with several actives and a fixed capsule size, the fumarate leaves more room for the rest of the formula. For a product that needs a large, soluble iron dose in a stick pack, the sulfate's mass may be part of the design rather than a problem.
The 30 mg row matters in the United States. A solid oral supplement at or above 30 mg of iron per dosage unit carries the accidental-overdose warning, and the fumarate reaches that threshold at about 91–97 mg of powder. A 100 mg capsule is over the line; a 60 mg capsule is under it.
Colour, taste and the blend
Colour is the first practical difference. The fumarate is orange-red to reddish-brown and opaque; the sulfate is pale blue-green and translucent when crystalline. In a white or pastel powder blend, the fumarate shows through; in a clear shell, both salts are visible, but only the sulfate dissolves into a coloured solution.
Taste follows solubility. The sulfate's acidic, metallic taste is immediate because it dissolves; the fumarate is chalky and largely insoluble, so the taste is flatter but the mouthfeel is gritty. A coated tablet hides both; a chewable or a drink mix does not.
Both salts are ferrous and both oxidise, but the sulfate has the extra sensitivity of its water of crystallisation: it can lose water in dry air and pick up moisture and oxidise in humid air. The fumarate is anhydrous but still reacts at the particle surface when moisture is present. Iron from either salt can catalyse the oxidation of oils and some vitamins, so the blend has to be tested as a blend, not only as a powder.
What the label has to say
In the European Union, the iron-source entry for a supplement is checked against Annex II to Directive 2002/46/EC, and the ingredient list must name the form that is actually in the drum. The nutrition declaration gives elemental iron in mg and as a share of the 14 mg reference intake. A label that names one salt while the drum contains the other is mislabelled, even if the iron figure is correct.
US labelling puts elemental iron in the Supplement Facts panel against an 18 mg Daily Value, with the salt named in the ingredient list. The 30 mg warning threshold is checked per dosage unit, as above. A switch from sulfate to fumarate changes the salt name, the salt mass and possibly the capsule size, so the artwork, the nutrition calculation and the batch record all have to change together.
When to choose which
Choose the fumarate when the dosage form is a capsule or a tablet, when the fill is tight, and when an insoluble, orange-red powder fits the colour and the taste of the product. It is the practical salt for a compact solid dose with a high iron figure per gram.
Choose the sulfate when the formula needs a soluble iron source, when an acidic solution is acceptable, and when the label already names the sulfate. It is the easier salt for a liquid or a stick pack, and its lower iron fraction is simply part of the mass calculation.
Neither choice is a substitution at the same weight. The ferrous fumarate product page carries the catalog specification; the ferrous sulfate page carries the soluble alternative; the grade page places both among the other iron sources; the iron pyrophosphate page covers the ferric option; the methods library explains the iron and identity tests; the quality page describes the release file.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation