06 Identity & adulteration

How we prove a neutral protease lot has the declared activity

Technical document 06 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · Neutral Protease

On this page
  1. Four independent checks
  2. The assay, the unit and the protein ratio
  3. XRD is the wrong tool for the protein
  4. Routes that can satisfy a weak test
  5. A specification that can be checked
  6. Five questions before qualification

Four independent checks stand behind a neutral protease lot: the organism and strain, the protein profile, the casein activity and the chain from sample to drum. None is sufficient alone. The activity figure is the one buyers look at first, and it is also the easiest for a different preparation to satisfy.

In one line

A neutral protease lot is only as strong as the agreement between its Bacillus strain, its protein profile, its casein assay and its lot record; the U/g number alone proves very little.

Four independent checks

The organism check asks whether the declared Bacillus subtilis strain is the one that was fermented, and whether the origin and fermentation records support it. The protein check asks whether the powder contains the expected protein profile. The activity check asks whether it cuts casein at the declared rate under the declared conditions. The record check asks whether the certificate, the pack and the retained sample all point to the same lot.

Identity checks · question and evidence
CheckQuestionEvidence
OrganismIs the declared Bacillus strain the one that was fermented?Strain declaration, origin record, fermentation description
ProteinDoes the protein profile fit the preparation?Total protein and gel bands
ActivityDoes it cut casein at the stated rate?U/g with substrate, pH, temperature and standard
RecordDoes the paperwork point to this drum?Lot code, COA and retained sample

Read together, the four describe a preparation. Read alone, each is incomplete: a strain name says nothing about activity, an activity figure says nothing about source, and a certificate without a lot code cannot be tied to the drum in front of you.

The assay, the unit and the protein ratio

The unit is whatever the method defines. In the common casein method, the substrate is held at pH 7.0 and 40 °C and one U releases 1 µg of tyrosine equivalent per minute, measured by Folin–Ciocalteu colour against a tyrosine standard. Other method sheets use pH 7.5 and 30 °C or 37 °C, so the certificate has to print the definition it followed. At 50,000 U/g the powder carries 50 U per milligram of preparation, not per milligram of protein.

Protein is measured by Bradford, BCA, Kjeldahl or another named method, and each carries a bias. The revealing number is the ratio: U per milligram of protein. Within one grade and one method it should be stable. A protein carrier lowers both activity and protein, so the ratio holds; heat damage lowers activity while protein is still measured, so the ratio falls. A ratio that drifts at constant U/g means the powder contains more protein for the same activity — a different recovery cut, an inactivated fraction or an undeclared carrier.

The ratio is a trend, not a purity specification. Neutral protease preparations are mixtures of proteins, so specific activity is only meaningful together with the assay and protein method that produced it. Track it inside one supplier's method; there is no universal cutoff to compare against.

XRD is the wrong tool for the protein

X-ray diffraction is sometimes requested as an identity test. A dried enzyme powder is amorphous, so it produces a broad halo instead of the sharp reflections of a crystal. That halo can look the same from lot to lot without saying which enzyme is present. XRD can detect a crystalline carrier or a crystalline contaminant, which is a useful composition check, but it cannot identify the protein.

A matching diffractogram is not proof that a lot is neutral protease. The identity case rests on the organism, the protein profile and the activity assay, read together. If a customer specification requires XRD, use it as a carrier check and put the identity claim on methods that can support it.

Routes that can satisfy a weak test

Adulteration routes · what passes and what detects them
RouteWhat passesWhat detects it
Carrier dilutionThe blend still assays at the declared U/gCarrier disclosure, mass balance, specific activity
Another proteaseCasein is cutProtein bands, strain record, a source-specific test
Heat-killed powderProtein and colour remainU/g falls and specific activity falls
Paper activityA number on the certificateIndependent assay by the named method
Different sourceThe word “protease” covers itStrain statement, origin record, supplier audit

These rows are checks, not charges. Most shipments match their paperwork. Testing U/g covers one check out of four; the remaining three are available on request. A gel pattern is a quick view of whether the protein looks like the qualified material; the strain record is a quick view of whether the organism matches the declaration.

A specification that can be checked

  • “Neutral protease (bacillolysin; EC 3.4.24.28) preparation from Bacillus subtilis, CAS 9025-39-2.”
  • “≥50,000 U/g by the casein method; the COA prints substrate, pH, temperature, time and standard.”
  • “As-is result; loss on drying ≤8.0% for the lot.”
  • “Protein and specific activity reported, with the protein method.”
  • “pH 6.5–7.5 (1% solution); ≥95% through 40 mesh.”
  • “Heavy metals Pb ≤3 · As ≤2 · Cd ≤1 · Hg ≤0.1 mg/kg; APC ≤10,000 cfu/g; yeast and mould ≤100 cfu/g; E. coli and Salmonella absent.”
  • “Carrier and side activities declared; no undeclared diluent.”

The final line carries weight. A dilution is acceptable only when its carrier is written into the specification and the certificate, not left to an email. A second enzyme activity follows the same rule: if the powder contains one, the description says so.

Five questions before qualification

  1. Which Bacillus strain was fermented, and is it B. subtilis?
  2. How is the U defined — substrate, pH, temperature, time and standard?
  3. Was the assay run as-is or on dried solids, and what did the lot's moisture test show?
  4. Which protein method was used, and what specific activity did it give?
  5. Does the powder contain a carrier or a second enzyme activity, and which document declares it?

If the method answer is “standard”, ask for the sheet. A carrier answer of “none” should come with a mass balance. The COA page shows where each answer lands on the certificate; the grades page covers dilution; the U versus AU page covers the unit; the product page carries the catalog limits; and the quality page describes the release workflow.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation