L-histidine vs L-histidine hydrochloride: the salt, the assay and the label
L-histidine free base and L-histidine hydrochloride are the same amino acid with different counter-ions and different masses. The free base is 155.15 g/mol and carries the whole mass as histidine; the hydrochloride monohydrate is 209.63 g/mol, of which about 74.0% is histidine, 16.9% chloride and 8.6% water. The salt dissolves more freely and gives an acidic solution; the free base gives a solution at pH 7.0–9.0. The assay percentages are calculated on different bases, so a 99% figure on one certificate does not mean the same thing as a 99% figure on the other.
The hydrochloride monohydrate is 74% histidine by mass, so a label written for the free base needs about a third more salt to deliver the same dose.
Two forms, two sets of numbers
The molecular weights do the work. The free base is C6H9N3O2 at 155.15 g/mol. The monohydrochloride monohydrate adds one HCl and one water, giving C6H9N3O2·HCl·H2O at 209.63 g/mol. The anhydrous hydrochloride, CAS 645-35-2, is 191.62 g/mol and carries no water of crystallisation.
| Line | Free base | Hydrochloride monohydrate |
|---|---|---|
| CAS | 71-00-1 | 5934-29-2 |
| Formula | C6H9N3O2 | C6H9N3O2·HCl·H2O |
| Molecular weight | 155.15 | 209.63 |
| Histidine per 1,000 mg | 1,000 mg | 740 mg |
| Chloride per 1,000 mg | None added | 169 mg |
| Water per 1,000 mg | None of crystallisation | 86 mg |
| pH | 7.0–9.0 (1% solution) | 3.0–5.0 (5% solution) |
| Label name | L-histidine | L-histidine hydrochloride |
The table is stoichiometric; a lot's assay and moisture move each figure by a percent or two, so calculate from the certificate. The numbers are not a quality ranking.
Solubility, pH and the chloride load
The free base dissolves to about 42 g/L at 25 °C, and the solution sits at pH 7.0–9.0. That is not strongly alkaline: the imidazole ring has a pKa near 6.0, so the free base buffers around the mildly acidic range and is close to neutral in water. The hydrochloride is freely soluble and acidic, around pH 3.0–5.0 at 5%. A concentrated stock, a cold process or a clear liquid that cannot carry the free base's solubility limit is where the salt earns its place.
Solubility is not the same as absorption, and it is not a reason by itself to change the label. What the salt buys is process room: more grams dissolve per litre and the solution starts acidic. What it costs is the chloride load and the water of crystallisation. At a 500 mg histidine dose the monohydrate brings about 114 mg of chloride, which matters in a low-sodium or chloride-sensitive formula and in a label that declares salt rather than histidine.
Neither form is a drop-in for the other in an existing formula, and solubility is not a reason to change the label by itself.
The dose arithmetic and the hydrate
The conversion factor for the monohydrate is 155.15 ÷ 209.63 = 0.740. To declare 500 mg of histidine, weigh 500 ÷ 0.740 = 676 mg of the monohydrate. To declare 1,000 mg, weigh 1,351 mg. Going the other way, 1,000 mg of the monohydrate is 740 mg of histidine, and 500 mg of the salt is 370 mg of histidine.
The anhydrous salt changes the factor to 155.15 ÷ 191.62 = 0.810. A specification that says only “hydrochloride” does not say whether the water is there. If the label arithmetic is built on the anhydrous factor and the drum contains the monohydrate, the same weigh-up delivers about 8.6% less histidine. Name the hydrate, report water or loss on drying, and use the certificate's figure rather than the theoretical one.
The assay basis adds a second correction: the free-base assay is calculated as histidine, the hydrochloride assay as the salt on the dried basis. A 99.0% salt assay is about 73.3% histidine after the salt factor, so the two percentages are not comparable without the conversion.
What the assay line actually measures
The free-base certificate reports 98.5–101.5% by HPLC on the dried basis. The hydrochloride certificate reports 99.0–101.0% as the salt on the dried basis, with water, chloride and pH beside it. The reference standard and the calculation differ, so the certificate should say which material the percentage refers to.
The rotation is the enantiomer check, and it is solvent-dependent. The free base in water reads about −39°, while the pharmacopoeial method for the same L form in 6 N hydrochloric acid reads about +12.6° to +14.0°. A salt certificate quoting the free-base window, or a free-base certificate quoting the acid window, is mixing two methods. The pH line is the quick form check: a free-base lot at pH 4 or a hydrochloride lot at pH 8 is a finding, not a rounding error.
Chloride is the direct counter-ion measurement. The free-base monograph limits chloride to 0.05%; the monohydrate carries about 16.9% by theory. A blend of the two forms lands in between, in proportion to the salt fraction. When the form is disputed, chloride plus pH plus water is stronger evidence than the assay percentage alone.
What the label has to say
In the EU, the ingredient list must name the form as it appears in the specification: “L-histidine” for the free base, “L-histidine hydrochloride” for the salt. The quantity per portion follows the form that is named. A label that says L-histidine while the drum contains the hydrochloride has two defects: the name is wrong, and the declared quantity overstates the histidine by about 26% of the salt's weight.
In the United States, the Supplement Facts panel declares the amount per serving, and the ingredient list carries the source. If the source is the hydrochloride, both have to agree on what the milligram figure refers to. L-histidine has no Daily Value, so no percentage is shown. A structure or function statement needs the DSHEA disclaimer and substantiation; a disease claim is not permitted. The label ingredient is L-histidine, not a histidine-containing dipeptide such as carnosine; the claim review is separate and belongs on the compliance page.
When to choose which
Choose the free base when the label has to say “L-histidine”, the dose is expressed as histidine, and the formula can carry pH 7–9. Choose the hydrochloride when the label names the salt, the dose is expressed as the salt, the formula needs a freely soluble ingredient at acidic pH, and the chloride is acceptable. If the label names the free base but the formula needs the salt's solubility, change the label or the formula; do not swap the drum and adjust the number afterwards.
The product hub carries the catalog free base; the grades page sets the form question in the wider range; the COA page shows the assay and rotation lines; the identity page explains how the base is distinguished from the salt; the methods section describes the chromatographic work, and the quality page covers release.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation