02.1 Citrulline vs malate

L-citrulline vs citrulline malate: dose, acid and the label

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · L-Citrulline

On this page
  1. The mass conversion
  2. The dose question is a conversion
  3. The acid the malate brings
  4. What each form fits
  5. What the label has to name
  6. When each one is the right choice

A gram of L-citrulline is a gram of citrulline; a gram of citrulline malate is roughly 0.57–0.72 g of citrulline and the rest malic acid. Matching the label figure therefore means weighing more powder, and the extra weight arrives with an acid load that changes the taste, the flavour system and the pH of the blend.

In one line

Per gram the free amino acid carries all of the citrulline and the malate carries 57–72%, so matching the label figure means weighing more powder and accepting more acid.

The mass conversion

Citrulline is 175.19 g/mol and malic acid is 134.09 g/mol. A 1:1 molar salt weighs 309.28 g/mol and holds 56.6% citrulline. Two citrulline units to one malic acid weigh 484.47 g/mol and hold 72.3%. A blend made at two parts citrulline to one part malic acid by mass holds 66.7%. All three are sold under the same name, which is why the ratio has to be stated with its basis rather than assumed.

Citrulline content and the powder a 3 g figure needs
FormCitrulline by massPowder for 3 g citrullineCitrulline in 1 g
L-citrulline100%3.0 g1,000 mg
Citrulline malate, 1:1 molar56.6%5.3 g566 mg
Citrulline malate, 2:1 molar72.3%4.2 g723 mg
Citrulline malate, 2:1 by mass66.7%4.5 g667 mg

The dose question is a conversion

The panel states a quantity, and the first thing to establish is what that quantity refers to. A panel reading “citrulline malate 6 g” delivers 3.4 g of citrulline at 56.6% or 4.3 g at 72.3%, a spread of almost a gram from the same label figure because the ratio is not on the label. A panel reading “citrulline 3 g” has already done the conversion for the buyer, and a tub of malate behind that panel needs 4.2–5.3 g of powder per serving.

That is the whole of the dose question on this page: arithmetic between the salt weight and the citrulline weight. It is not a recommendation about how much anyone should take, and it does not depend on what the ingredient is expected to do. What it does decide is whether the serving fits the pack. A capsule holds hundreds of milligrams rather than grams, so any multi-gram serving becomes a powder or a large capsule count, and the malate makes that count larger.

The acid the malate brings

Malic acid has two carboxyl groups with pKa values near 3.40 and 5.11, so a solution of the malate reads clearly acidic, while the free amino acid's 5% solution sits at pH 5.0–7.0. In a flavoured powder that difference is a taste decision: the malate supplies some of the sharpness a fruit flavour expects, and the formulator adjusts sweetener and buffer around it. In a capsule it is a compatibility question for the shell and any coating, and in a blend it is a question for any acid-sensitive partner.

Acidity also travels with water. Malic acid is hygroscopic, and a malate powder picks up water more readily than the free amino acid, which shows as stickiness in the hopper and caking in an opened pack. If the material is a dry blend rather than a reacted salt, the two components can segregate, so the acid load in a scoop is not guaranteed to match the average on the certificate.

What each form fits

The free amino acid fits a capsule or tablet where the fill is measured in hundreds of milligrams, and it fits a neutral powder where the flavour system is doing the work. Its near-neutral solution leaves the acid decision to the rest of the formula and adds no acid load to a blend that already carries one.

The malate fits a flavoured stick or drink where the acidity is wanted and the serving is measured in grams. It is the harder material in a dry room and the easier one to taste, and it makes the label arithmetic longer because the ratio has to be defined. Neither form is excluded from any of these packs; the difference is how much room the formula has and how much acid it can carry.

What the label has to name

The ingredient list has to name the material that is in the tub. Under the EU labelling regulation, the US supplement facts rules and the retained UK rules, the declared ingredient and the declared quantity must match; a tub of malate cannot be sold under a panel that says L-citrulline, and the reverse is equally true. Where a citrulline figure is derived from a malate, the derivation and the ratio belong in the specification and in the label review, not in an assumption made at the filling line.

A “2:1” claim on the front of a pack means nothing until it says whether the ratio is molar or by mass, because the two readings are 72.3% and 66.7% citrulline. Ask for the definition in writing, then check it against the certificate's citrulline and malic acid results.

When each one is the right choice

Choose the free amino acid when the panel already says L-citrulline, when the capsule is the pack, when the blend carries an acid-sensitive partner, or when the specification is written around the rotation and the titration. Choose the malate when the panel names it, when the serving is a flavoured powder, and when the acid is part of the design rather than an accident.

Choosing a form for a new formula
If the formula isThen the form isBecause
A capsule at 500 mg fillL-citrullineAll of the mass is citrulline
A flavoured stick packEither, ratio declaredThe acid is a taste decision
A blend with a carbonateL-citrullineNo added acid
A panel naming the malateCitrulline malateThe name and the powder must match
A spec around rotation and titrationL-citrullineThe malate does not meet those lines

The parent comparison is on the grade page, the identity tests that separate the forms are on the identity page, and the label rules for each market are on the compliance page. The catalog specification for the free amino acid is on the product page, and the assay basis is explained in the COA page.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation