02 Grade comparison

L-citrulline or citrulline malate: choosing a grade

Technical document 02 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · L-Citrulline

On this page
  1. Why a single molecule has grades
  2. The two forms side by side
  3. Water, flow and acidity
  4. What the label figure needs in powder
  5. Writing the specification for each form
  6. When the switch is the wrong move

L-citrulline and citrulline malate are different ingredients, not two purities of one. The free amino acid is 100% citrulline by mass and its 5% solution sits at pH 5.0–7.0; the malate carries 57–72% citrulline depending on the ratio and reads acidic. A switch between them changes the milligram figure, the taste and the name on the panel.

In one line

The malate is a different ingredient, not a different mesh: it carries 57–72% citrulline by mass and an acidic solution, so the label, the milligram figure and the taste all move together.

Why a single molecule has grades

Purity is not the question here. Both forms can meet their own certificate at 98% or better. The question is what the powder contains besides citrulline, and the answer decides how much powder a label figure needs, how the blend behaves in the plant, and what the ingredient list is allowed to say. A purchase order that says “citrulline” without naming the form leaves several quite different materials open.

The form also decides which specification applies. The catalog sheet on the L-citrulline product page describes the free amino acid: titration assay 98.5–101.5% on the dried basis, rotation +21.5° to +23.5°, loss on drying ≤0.5%. None of those limits can be lifted onto a malate and expected to mean the same thing, because the mass now includes malic acid.

The two forms side by side

Citrulline is 175.19 g/mol and malic acid is 134.09 g/mol. A 1:1 molar salt is therefore 56.6% citrulline; two citrulline units to one malic acid gives 484.47 g/mol of salt, of which 350.38 g is citrulline, or 72.3%. Commercial material also uses a mass ratio of two parts citrulline to one part malic acid, which is 66.7% citrulline. The convention explains why a “citrulline malate 2:1” label can declare anything between roughly 67% and 72%.

Citrulline content by form and ratio
FormCitrulline by mass5% solutionPanel names
L-citrulline100%pH 5.0–7.0L-citrulline
Citrulline malate, 1:1 molar56.6%AcidicCitrulline malate
Citrulline malate, 2:1 molar72.3%AcidicCitrulline malate
Citrulline malate, 2:1 by mass66.7%AcidicCitrulline malate

The ratio convention is not a detail to leave to the supplier. Ask whether the figure on the certificate is molar or by mass, and ask for the malic acid result beside the citrulline result so the ratio can be calculated rather than accepted.

Water, flow and acidity

The free amino acid is a crystalline powder at 40 mesh. It takes up little water in ordinary handling, flows predictably, and is the easier of the two to keep as a free-flowing solid through a capsule line. Its solution is close to neutral, so it contributes almost no acid to a blend.

Malic acid is hygroscopic, and a malate powder therefore takes water more readily than the free amino acid. In an open room it softens, sticks to the dosator and cakes in the bag. The effect grows if the material is a dry blend of citrulline and malic acid rather than a reacted salt: the two components can segregate, and a sample taken from the top of a drum may not represent the acid load at the bottom.

Acidity is the second difference with practical consequences. The malate's solution is acidic enough to matter to an enteric coating, to a carbonate in the same blend, and to the flavour system in a drink. The free amino acid leaves that decision to the rest of the formula. Moisture behaviour is followed further on the stability page.

What the label figure needs in powder

A formula is usually written around a citrulline figure, not around a salt weight. Dividing that figure by the citrulline fraction gives the powder weight: 3 g of citrulline is 3 g of the free amino acid, 5.3 g of a 1:1 malate, or 4.2 g of a 72.3% malate. Between the two malate conventions the multiplier runs from about 1.4 to 1.8.

That multiplier decides the dosage form. A 500 mg capsule can hold 500 mg of the free amino acid but only about 360 mg of citrulline as a 72% malate, so a formula built on capsules may not reach the same label figure without more capsules. A stick pack or a drink mix has the room; the malate's acid then becomes a flavour decision. None of this is a claim about what the ingredient does in the body; it is the arithmetic that decides which form fits the pack.

Writing the specification for each form

For the free amino acid the catalog sheet is the starting point: name, CAS 372-75-8, assay by titration on the dried basis, identification by IR and ninhydrin, rotation with its conditions, loss on drying, residue on ignition, pH at 5%, mesh, metals and microbiology. Each line is measurable on that material without interpretation.

A malate specification needs different lines: citrulline content, malic acid content, the ratio and its basis, pH, water, and particle size. A certificate that reports a single “assay 98%” for citrulline malate defines nothing, because the same total can be built from different proportions of the two components. Ask for both figures, then do the division yourself.

When the switch is the wrong move

Do not substitute the malate where the panel already says L-citrulline. The ingredient name, the declared quantity and the certificate all change together, and a brand that keeps the old artwork with the new powder has a mismatch that a label review will find after the print run. The reverse is equally true: a formula written and tested around the malate is not the same formula with the free amino acid dropped in at the same weight.

Skip the malate when the blend carries an acid-sensitive partner, when the capsule is already at its fill limit, or when the customer's specification is written around the free amino acid's rotation and assay. Skip the free amino acid when the acid is part of the flavour design and the label already names the malate. The label, the specification and the purchase order should name one form, once.

The form-by-form comparison for a powder blend is on the citrulline versus malate page. The release tests are on the COA page, and the market rules for the two names are on the compliance page. The specification note explains why a limit without a method is not a specification.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation