06 Identity & adulteration

How we prove a creatine lot is creatine monohydrate

Technical document 06 · Reviewed 2026-11-18 · Creatine Monohydrate

On this page
  1. Four checks that together identify the lot
  2. Assay, creatinine and LOD: reading the numbers together
  3. IR, HPLC and the crystal form
  4. Substitution routes to test for
  5. Writing the identity block
  6. Five questions that close the file

Identity is proved by four lines together: an IR spectrum that matches the reference, an HPLC assay on the dried basis, the water of crystallisation measured by loss on drying, and the impurity panel for creatinine, dicyandiamide and residue on ignition. The assay alone cannot prove the hydrate or exclude another creatine salt. The batch COA carries the results; the specification fixes the limits.

In one line

A creatine lot is proved by the combination of IR, HPLC, the water of crystallisation and the impurity panel, not by the assay alone.

Four checks that together identify the lot

Each test answers a different question, and each has a blind spot. The certificate is useful when the layers are read together rather than as a list of separate passes.

Four layers of identity · creatine monohydrate
LayerTestWhat it provesWhat it misses
PaperLot code, product name, CAS, manufacturer, packTraceability from the certificate to the drumNothing about the chemistry
MolecularIR against a reference spectrumThe functional groups of creatine are presentHydrate stoichiometry and purity
ChromatographicHPLC retention time, peak purity and assayCreatine content and a clean peakWater, inorganic residue and a co-eluting impurity
Solid stateLoss on drying, residue on ignition, creatinine, dicyandiamide, XRD if neededThe hydrate, the inorganic load and the process markersIdentity on its own; LOD is not specific to water

The paper layer matters: a correct certificate can belong to another drum, grade or manufacturer. The lot code should match the drum, pack and retained sample.

Assay, creatinine and LOD: reading the numbers together

The first check is a mass balance, not a single figure. The catalog assay is 99.0–101.0% on the dried basis, and the monohydrate carries roughly 12% water of crystallisation. An as-is creatine content near 87% is therefore consistent with a 99% dried-basis assay and an LOD near 12%; the water is expected. A certificate that reports a 99% assay with an LOD of 2% is describing a different solid, not a cleaner monohydrate.

Creatinine and dicyandiamide are the impurity side of the balance. Creatinine is the cyclised degradation product, and it rises when the powder has seen moisture and heat. Dicyandiamide is a nitrogen-rich process impurity associated with the cyanamide route. Both are capped far below the assay, at 100 ppm and 50 ppm. A lot at 90 ppm creatinine and 45 ppm dicyandiamide passes but leaves little room for a formula that adds heat or water.

Residue on ignition is the inorganic side. A result near 0.1% points to a salt load or an incomplete desalting step; a low result is consistent with an organic salt that has been washed. Together they rule out several substitutions before a spectrum is run.

IR, HPLC and the crystal form

IR is a fingerprint. The spectrum should be compared with a reference run under the same preparation, and the report should name the instrument and the reference. A match supports the functional groups of creatine; it does not prove that the powder is the monohydrate, because a different creatine salt can share several bands.

HPLC adds retention time, peak purity and the assay. The retention time should match the standard, and the peak purity or diode-array comparison should show a single component. A co-eluting impurity can hide inside a clean-looking peak, which is why the impurity panel is run as separate lines. The assay is calculated on the dried basis, using that lot's LOD; a certificate that does not state the basis cannot be recalculated.

X-ray diffraction is the tie-breaker when the LOD is outside the expected hydrate range or when a supplier claims a crystal form that the certificate does not describe. The monohydrate and the anhydrous form have different patterns, and a physical mixture shows both. XRD is not needed on every lot, but it is the right test when LOD and assay disagree, or when a “micronized” claim needs separating from a different hydrate.

Substitution routes to test for

Creatine is not an expensive material, so the common substitution is a different creatine form sold under the monohydrate name, or a process impurity above the specification. The label and the specification have to name the salt, not only the creatine content.

Creatine forms and impurities that can pass a creatine assay
MaterialWhat changesTest that shows it
Creatine nitrateDifferent salt; nitrate loadIon chromatography for nitrate, IR, assay
Creatine hydrochlorideDifferent salt; chloride and lower solution pHChloride test, pH, IR
Creatine ethyl esterDifferent molecule with an ester groupHPLC retention and peak identity, IR
Anhydrous creatineNo water of crystallisation; a different solid formLOD far below 12.0%, XRD, IR
DicyandiamideA nitrogen-rich process impurityHPLC against the 50 ppm limit
CreatinineA degradation product from moisture and heatHPLC against the 100 ppm limit
Other creatine salts or diluentsDifferent label ingredient or lower creatine contentAssay, IR, LOD, full composition

Creatine nitrate and creatine hydrochloride are legitimate ingredients when they are declared and labelled as such. The defect is an undeclared substitution, not the existence of the salt. A high nitrogen figure is not proof either: the assay is HPLC, and a nitrogen method would read nitrate or dicyandiamide as creatine.

Writing the identity block

The identity block should be a set of release tests, not a narrative. Write it so a laboratory can repeat every line and a buyer can reject against a named limit.

  • “Creatine monohydrate, C₄H₉N₃O₂·H₂O, CAS 6020-87-7; single salt, no other creatine form or diluent.”
  • “IR conforms to the reference spectrum; instrument and preparation named.”
  • “Assay 99.0–101.0% by HPLC on the dried basis; peak purity reported.”
  • “Creatinine ≤100 ppm; dicyandiamide ≤50 ppm; LOD ≤12.0%; residue on ignition ≤0.1%.”
  • “Heavy metals Pb ≤3 · As ≤2 · Cd ≤1 · Hg ≤0.1 mg/kg; microbiology as catalogued.”
  • “Mesh 80 or 200, or a micronized D50/D90 by laser diffraction when ordered.”

If the material is a blend, the block has to name every component; a single creatine assay cannot describe a blend. If the material is micronized, the particle-size line belongs beside the identity block, because micronization changes the powder, not the molecule.

Five questions that close the file

  1. Which IR reference and preparation were used, and can you send the spectrum?
  2. Is the HPLC assay calculated on the dried basis, and what does the peak-purity check show?
  3. What are the creatinine and dicyandiamide results for this lot, and which methods produced them?
  4. What is the LOD, and if it is outside the usual monohydrate range, is there an XRD or IR check of the solid form?
  5. Is this a single salt, and are any other creatine forms, carriers or diluents present?

Five direct answers amount to an identity file. A single assay figure does not. The product page carries the catalog specification; the COA page shows where each figure sits on the certificate; the grade page covers mesh; the stability page explains the creatinine route; the FTIR method note and the XRD note describe the instruments.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation