Soy isolate or concentrate: choosing a soy protein grade
Soy protein is sold as flour, concentrate and isolate, and the three are different label ingredients with different protein densities and different amounts of fiber, ash and fat. For a powder, a stick pack or a bar, the practical choice is usually isolate against concentrate: the isolate gives more protein per gram of powder, the concentrate keeps the fiber and the minerals. The protein number on the front of the bag is the start of the comparison, not the end of it.
The grade is the protein density and the fiber and ash that come with it, not the number on the front of the bag.
Why the family has several members
The Codex standard for soy protein products defines the family by protein content on a dry basis, calculated with N × 6.25: soy protein flour at 50% or more and below 65%, soy protein concentrate at 65% or more and below 90%, and soy protein isolate at 90% or more. The definition excludes added vitamins, minerals, amino acids and food additives, so the percentage has to come from the soy protein itself.
The processes behind the grades are different, not just the numbers. A concentrate is made by washing soluble sugars out of defatted soy flour with alcohol or an acid solution, which leaves much of the fiber and the minerals in the powder. An isolate is made by dissolving the protein at alkaline pH, precipitating it near its isoelectric point around pH 4.5, washing the curd, neutralising it and spray drying. The isolate process removes more of the fiber and the soluble ash, and that is where the protein density comes from.
CAS 9010-10-0 identifies the soy protein material, not the grade. Two certificates can carry the same CAS and describe a concentrate and an isolate.
The family at a glance
| Grade | Protein, dry basis | Fiber | Ash and fat | Usual fit | Label name |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Soy protein flour | 50% to below 65% | Retained | Higher than the isolate | Bakery, cereal, blends | Soy flour or soy protein flour |
| Soy protein concentrate | 65% to below 90% | Retained | Higher than the isolate | Bars, textured products, blends | Soy protein concentrate |
| Soy protein isolate | ≥90.0% | Removed by the process | Ash ≤5.0%, fat ≤1.0% | Sports powders, sticks, bars | Soy protein isolate |
| Agglomerated or instantized isolate | Same as the isolate | Same as the isolate | Same as the isolate | Sachets, spoonable powders | Soy protein isolate, with the form named |
The table maps the family; it is not a recommendation. The isolate row is the catalogue specification on this site; the concentrate band comes from the Codex definition. Every row is its own specification, and each certificate must identify which row it covers.
What changes in the powder
The isolate is a spray-dried powder specified at 80 mesh, with agglomerated and instantized forms available on request. Mesh, bulk density, dust and wetting rate change with the form, and they change how the powder behaves on a filling line. A finer powder disperses quickly but makes more dust; an agglomerated powder wets without lumps but fills a scoop differently.
The isolate dispersion is opaque and does not form a clear solution. That is a property of soy protein at the concentrations used in a drink, not a defect in the mesh. A formulator who needs a clear beverage has to change the protein or the format, not ask for a finer sieve cut. The concentrate behaves differently again: it carries fiber and can be granular or textured, which is useful in a bar or a textured product and awkward in a fine powder blend.
Colour and odour move with the process. Both grades are off-white to cream, and both can carry a beany or cereal note that strengthens with moisture and heat. The isolate is not automatically the more neutral of the two; the drying step and the storage history decide that.
What changes at the target dose
The dose calculation runs on the as-is protein content, not on the dry-basis figure. At the 7.0% moisture limit, 90.0% dry basis is 83.7% as-is, so 20 g of protein needs 23.9 g of isolate. A concentrate at 65.0% protein and the same 7.0% moisture is 60.5% as-is, so the same 20 g needs 33.1 g. The 9.2 g difference is powder the rest of the formula has to carry, and it arrives with fiber, ash and carbohydrate.
| Protein target | Soy isolate | Soy concentrate | Extra powder |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 g | 23.9 g | 33.1 g | 9.2 g |
| 30 g | 35.8 g | 49.6 g | 13.8 g |
The concentrate band runs up to just below 90%, so the real figure depends on the lot. At 70.0% protein and 7.0% moisture the 20 g figure is 30.7 g, not 33.1 g. The calculation has to be run on the actual certificate, not on the lowest number in the band.
The same arithmetic applies to a scoop. A 25 g scoop of isolate at 83.7% as-is delivers 20.9 g of protein; the same scoop of a 60.5% concentrate delivers 15.1 g. Rounding the powder weight rather than the protein puts the wrong figure on the panel.
What the specification should say
- The grade and the process: soy protein isolate, spray-dried, 80 mesh; name agglomeration or instantizing if the line needs it.
- Protein at ≥90.0% dry basis, measured by Kjeldahl with the N × 6.25 factor, excluding added amino acids, vitamins and minerals.
- Moisture ≤7.0%, ash ≤5.0%, fat ≤1.0% and pH 6.5–7.5, each with its method and basis.
- Particle size ≥95% through 80 mesh, with the test method stated.
- The soy allergen statement and the cross-contact controls.
- No other protein or nitrogen source added; non-GMO or identity-preserved status where the label relies on it.
A specification that says only “soy protein” leaves the supplier free to interpret the grade. The name on the specification, the name on the certificate and the name in the ingredient list have to be the same name.
When the other grade misfits
The isolate is the wrong choice when the formula benefits from the fiber and the texture the concentrate brings, when the serving can carry the extra powder, or when the bar matrix needs the water-binding that comes with the non-protein fraction. The concentrate is the wrong choice when the serving cannot carry the extra powder, when the carbohydrate and fiber line has a hard ceiling, or when the label is built around a higher protein density.
The protein number alone does not decide it. The decision comes from the dose, the matrix, the label and the certificate. The arithmetic behind the two grades is set out on soy isolate versus concentrate; the tests behind the numbers are on the COA page; the catalogue limits are on the soy protein isolate product page; and the label rules are on the compliance page.
In this document
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation