Magnesium taurate or glycinate: choosing a magnesium salt
Magnesium taurate and magnesium bisglycinate are both 1:2 magnesium salts, and they deliver the same nutrient at very different masses. The taurate carries 8.0–9.0% elemental magnesium on the dried basis; the glycinate carries 13.5–14.2%. A formula that needs 100 mg of magnesium therefore needs about 1.1–1.25 g of taurate or about 0.70–0.74 g of glycinate, and that difference decides the capsule size, the tablet weight and the label.
At 8–9% magnesium, taurate needs about 1.6 times the powder of a 14% glycinate for the same dose, so the salt choice is a fill-weight decision before it is a label decision.
The salt is the ingredient, the magnesium is the nutrient
A label names the salt in the ingredient list and declares the magnesium in the nutrition panel. Those are two different statements, and a formula has to satisfy both. Magnesium taurate is the magnesium salt of taurine, Mg(C₂H₆NO₃S)₂, with a molar mass of about 272.6 g/mol. Magnesium bisglycinate is the magnesium salt of glycine, Mg(C₂H₄NO₂)₂, at about 172.4 g/mol. Both are 1:2 salts. The anion is most of the mass in each case, which is why the elemental magnesium percentage is a minority figure.
In the taurate, magnesium is 8.9% of the anhydrous salt and the taurate is 91.1%. In the glycinate, magnesium is 14.1% and the glycinate is 85.9%. The catalog ranges sit around those figures. Neither salt is a generic “magnesium”, and a purchase order that names only the metal has not selected either one.
The two salts side by side
| Salt | Mg, dried basis | Powder per 100 mg Mg | pH (5%) | Standard form | Watch |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Magnesium taurate | 8.0–9.0% (EDTA) | 1,111–1,250 mg | 5.0–7.0 | 60 mesh; 0.50–0.80 g/mL | Low Mg; LOD ≤10.0%; hygroscopic |
| Magnesium bisglycinate | 13.5–14.2% (EDTA) | 704–741 mg | 8.5–11.5 | 40 mesh; 0.55–0.90 g/mL | Alkaline; free glycine; hydrate state |
The mass column uses the catalog range and no water correction. At the 10.0% loss-on-drying limit, the taurate figure rises to about 1,235–1,389 mg; at the glycinate's 8.0% limit, it rises to about 765–805 mg. The certificate for the lot is what the fill calculation should use, not the midpoint of a catalog range.
What the powder does in the plant
The taurate is specified at 60 mesh, with at least 90% passing a 250 µm sieve, and at a bulk density of 0.50–0.80 g/mL. The glycinate is a 40 mesh powder at 0.55–0.90 g/mL. Mesh is not a quality ranking. It is a flow, blending and dissolution decision, and a change of mesh is a change of process even when the chemistry is the same.
The pH separates the two more sharply than the mesh does. The taurate suspension sits at 5.0–7.0, close to neutral; the glycinate sits at 8.5–11.5. In a blend with an acid-sensitive component, or in a stick pack where the powder is dispersed in water, that difference is part of the formulation. It is also a useful identity signal: a taurate lot that reads alkaline is a reason to ask what else the drum contains.
Water is the third difference. The taurate limit is 10.0% loss on drying against 8.0% for the glycinate. The wider limit is not a licence to ship wet powder; it reflects a salt that tolerates water while its dried-basis magnesium stays in range. The as-is magnesium falls as the water rises, and the powder's flow and caking behaviour follow it.
Dose, fill and capsule count
Start from the elemental dose and divide by the magnesium fraction. For 100 mg of magnesium, the taurate needs 1,111–1,250 mg of powder and the glycinate needs 704–741 mg, before any excipient. Take a size 00 capsule, about 0.95 mL. A fill at 0.65 g/mL weighs about 620 mg; from the taurate that is roughly 50–56 mg of magnesium, and from the glycinate 83–88 mg. The taurate therefore needs two to three capsules for a 100 mg claim across the density range; the glycinate needs one to two.
At 200 mg of magnesium the gap widens: 2.2–2.5 g of taurate against 1.4–1.5 g of glycinate. In a tablet, 1.1–1.25 g of taurate is already a large tablet before excipients, while 0.7–0.74 g of glycinate is a more usual weight. In a stick pack or sachet, 1–3 g of powder is normal, so the taurate mass fits more easily; the scoop size and the taste are the constraints there.
These are planning figures, not fill-weight guarantees. The assay range, the water content and the bulk density of the lot all move the final number, and a press or capsule trial is what settles it. The taurate versus glycinate page works the arithmetic through dose by dose.
Write the specification for the salt you are buying
A specification copied from one salt onto the other will fail, and the supplier will be right to reject it. The magnesium range, the pH, the mesh and the identity test are all different. The specification should name the salt, the assay basis and the method, and it should say which tests prove the anion.
- “Magnesium taurate, CAS 334824-43-0; magnesium 8.0–9.0% on the dried basis by complexometric EDTA.”
- “Identification: taurate reaction and infrared spectrum conform to the magnesium taurate reference.”
- “Loss on drying ≤10.0%; pH of 5% suspension 5.0–7.0; ≥90% through 60 mesh; bulk density 0.50–0.80 g/mL.”
- “No added magnesium oxide, other magnesium salts or free taurine.”
For the glycinate the equivalent lines are 13.5–14.2% magnesium, glycine 84.0–88.0%, a Mg : glycine ratio of 1.95–2.05, free glycine ≤1.0% and loss on drying ≤8.0%. A single “magnesium” specification cannot cover both, and a certificate that reports only magnesium cannot tell you which one you received.
When switching is the wrong move
A salt switch is a change control, not a substitution. If the capsule count is fixed and the label is approved, the taurate's extra mass may not fit, and the glycinate may be the practical choice. If the label names taurate, the reverse switch is a label change as well, even if the magnesium declaration stays the same.
The label is part of the switch. In the European Union the ingredient list must name the salt and the nutrition declaration reports elemental magnesium in milligrams and as a percentage of the 375 mg reference intake; in the United States the Supplement Facts panel reports milligrams and a percentage of the 420 mg Daily Value. A new salt means a new ingredient name and a new calculation, not only a new drum.
Do not switch for a claim. The authorised magnesium wording, where a brand uses it, is tied to the magnesium dose and the market's rules, not to the anion. The salt choice is a question of mass, pH, flow, dosage form and label, and it should be settled on those terms. A switch needs a new fill trial, a stability check, a new nutrition declaration and new artwork before the first production lot.
The magnesium taurate product page carries the catalog specification. The magnesium bisglycinate page carries the other specification, and its grade page explains the hydrate variants. The label rules for both salts are on the compliance page.
In this document
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation