Lecithin vs phosphatidylcholine: the mixture and the isolate
Lecithin and phosphatidylcholine are related the way a mixed fruit juice and a single-fruit concentrate are related: one is the whole mixture, the other is a fraction of it. A PC grade is standardised on one phospholipid class, while lecithin is standardised on the total phosphatide fraction. The label, the dose and the specification follow that difference.
Lecithin is the mixture and phosphatidylcholine is one fraction of it: the dose weight, the label name and the specification follow the name on the certificate.
What lecithin is
Lecithin is a mixture by definition. It contains phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylethanolamine, phosphatidylinositol and phosphatidic acid, plus oil, sterols and glycolipids. The US GRAS regulation describes it as a naturally occurring mixture of phosphatides, and the EU additive entry covers lecithins and their fractions together. The mixture is the commercial product, not an intermediate on the way to one class.
A 60% lecithin has about 60% phosphatide and about 40% other material. PC is one component of that 60%, so a “60% lecithin” is not a “60% PC” ingredient. The gap between those two readings is the most common source of a wrong capsule weight.
What a phosphatidylcholine grade is
To make a PC grade, the lecithin is first deoiled, then extracted with ethanol, which dissolves PC more readily than PE or PI. The soluble fraction is concentrated and, if a higher figure is needed, fractionated again or polished chromatographically. The output is sold on its PC content, with concentrates at 70% or 90%.
PC is measured by a class-specific method, typically HPLC with an evaporative light-scattering or charged-aerosol detector, or TLC with densitometry. Neither acetone-insoluble matter nor a phosphorus calculation separates the classes. A PC certificate that reports only AI has not measured the grade's defining figure.
Hydrogenated PC and lyso-PC are separate products. Hydrogenation saturates the fatty acids and changes the oxidation behaviour; enzymatic hydrolysis removes one fatty acid and increases water dispersibility.
Lecithin and a PC grade compared
| Property | Lecithin | Phosphatidylcholine grade |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | The phospholipid mixture plus oil | A fraction standardised on PC |
| Specification basis | AI, phospholipids, class profile | PC by HPLC or TLC |
| PC content | A part of the phosphatide fraction | The declared figure |
| Balance | PE, PI, PA, oil, sterols | Other phospholipids and residual oil |
| Function in a formula | Emulsifier, mixed phospholipid source | Declared PC dose; dispersed systems |
| Label name | Lecithin (soya) | Phosphatidylcholine (soya) |
| Allergen | Soy declaration if soy-derived | Soy declaration if soy-derived |
The allergen row is easy to overlook. A soy-derived PC is still a soy ingredient for labelling purposes, and a soy-free claim requires a different plant source.
Dose arithmetic and the label basis
Work from the declared ingredient. A lecithin claim uses the weight of the mixture. A phospholipid claim divides by the phospholipid figure, or by the AI figure where that is the declared basis. A PC claim divides by the PC figure. Using the wrong divisor is the usual error.
For 100 mg PC, a lecithin with 20% PC needs 500 mg, while a 90% PC grade needs about 111 mg. For 300 mg PC, the same two products need 1,500 mg and 333 mg. The 20% and 90% are examples; the certificate supplies the real divisor.
A 60% phospholipid figure is not interchangeable with a 60% PC figure. If the brief uses them as if they were the same, the capsule weight can be wrong by a factor of three. Write the declared ingredient and the basis into the specification.
If the label declares choline, divide by the choline figure, not by the lecithin or PC weight. PC contains choline in its head group, and a choline claim has its own conditions in the destination market.
What the label and the regulatory file have to say
In the EU, lecithin is E322 and appears on the ingredient list as lecithin, with the soy source declared. A PC ingredient is named phosphatidylcholine; if it is soy-derived, the soy declaration remains. The E322 entry covers lecithins and fractions obtained by physical procedures; whether a particular PC grade is sold under that entry or as a separate ingredient depends on how it is made and named, so the buyer's regulatory team checks it.
In the US, lecithin is the common name in 21 CFR 184.1400, while phosphatidylcholine is a different ingredient name for the Supplement Facts panel. Soy is a major allergen, so a soy-derived PC must declare soy.
A certificate for one form does not support a label for the other. Match the label, the certificate and the market file to the same name.
Which one the formula needs
Choose lecithin for emulsification, for a mixed phosphatide source, or for a formula that can carry the oil and the other classes. Choose a PC grade for a declared PC dose or a system built around one class. Choose neither for a soy-free label; change the source.
Changing form is a change control, not a weighing adjustment. It alters the mass, the ingredient name, the allergen statement and the regulatory citation, and it should be documented before the first batch.
The catalog specification is on the soy lecithin product page; the phosphatidylcholine page is the separate product; the grades page shows where this comparison sits in the range; the COA page explains how the figures are reported; the compliance page explains the market entries, and the identity page covers the profile tests.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation