06 Identity & adulteration

How we prove a fish oil lot is the declared oil

Technical document 06 · Reviewed 2026-11-20 · Fish Oil

On this page
  1. Four layers that have to agree
  2. The EPA to DHA ratio and the minor acids
  3. Why XRD does not identify a liquid oil
  4. Where substitutions show up
  5. Writing identity into the specification
  6. Five questions to put to a supplier

A fish oil lot is identified by four things that have to agree: the species and source, the lipid form, the full fatty-acid profile and the oxidation state. The EPA+DHA total alone is not identity, because a blend, a lower-grade oil or an oxidised oil can hit the same total. CAS 8002-50-4 covers fish oil as a class and does not name the species.

In one line

Identity is the full fatty-acid profile, the EPA and DHA ratio, the intact lipid form and the species record, because an EPA+DHA total can be blended to order.

Four layers that have to agree

Identity is a set of agreeing measurements, not one certificate line. Each layer answers a different question, and a supplier who answers only the assay has described the concentration, not the oil.

Four layers of fish oil identity
LayerQuestionEvidence
SourceWhich fish, from where, refined by whom?Species statement and traceability record
FormTriglyceride, ethyl ester or re-esterified?Intact-lipid analysis by HPLC or GC
ProfileIs the fatty-acid pattern consistent with the source?GC-FAME with the chromatogram
OxidationIs the oil fresh?PV, p-AV, TOTOX, free fatty acid

The certificate answers the profile and the oxidation state. The source lives in the supplier file, and the form is a declaration until someone analyses the intact lipid. All four layers must describe the same lot, with one code tying the certificate, the pack and the retained sample together.

The EPA to DHA ratio and the minor acids

Natural fish oil has more EPA than DHA, usually at an EPA to DHA ratio around 1.2–1.8 for anchovy and sardine. The catalog 18/12 designation sits at 1.5 nominal; the full range of 18–22% EPA and 12–16% DHA spans about 1.13–1.83. A ratio outside the source's normal range can be a blend, a concentrate or a different species. The ratio is a consistency check, not a specification unless the buyer writes one.

Fatty-acid markers and what a shift suggests
MarkerTypical in fish oilWhat a shift suggests
EPA (C20:5 n-3)18–22% in this gradeDilution or a different source
DHA (C22:6 n-3)12–16% in this gradeDilution, algal oil or a concentrate
DPA (C22:5 n-3)Present, minorSource change; it is not EPA or DHA
Palmitic (C16:0)Present, major saturateVegetable or animal fat dilution
Linoleic (C18:2 n-6)LowSeed-oil dilution
CholesterolPresentFalls as vegetable oil rises
PhytosterolsLowRise with vegetable oil

The minor acids are the useful part. A blend built to hit 18% EPA and 12% DHA can still show a linoleic figure and a phytosterol pattern that a marine oil does not have. A concentrate can hit almost any ratio, so the ratio alone does not prove a natural oil; the form and the sterol pattern sit beside it.

Why XRD does not identify a liquid oil

XRD reads the spacing of planes in a crystal lattice. Refined fish oil is a liquid at room temperature and has no lattice, so a diffraction pattern from the neat oil says nothing about the species. The technique belongs to the powder: the starch carrier is crystalline enough to diffract, and the pattern can show the carrier phase or a crystalline foreign phase.

On a powder certificate, an XRD line is a check on the carrier, not on the oil. It says nothing about the fatty-acid profile or the species. For the oil, the identity instruments are GC-FAME for the profile and, where the form is disputed, intact-lipid analysis by HPLC or GC. FTIR can give a fingerprint for a quick comparison but does not quantify EPA and DHA.

Where substitutions show up

Common fish oil substitutions and the signals
RouteSignalTest
Vegetable oil dilutionLinoleic and phytosterols up; cholesterol downGC profile, sterol and cholesterol panel
Lower-grade fish oilRatio and DPA driftGC against a retained reference
Oxidised oilPV and p-AV up; fishy odourOxidation panel with TOTOX
Ethyl ester sold as triglycerideForm mismatch; label ingredient wrongIntact-lipid analysis by HPLC or GC
Fish liver oil sold as body oilVitamin A and D highVitamin assay and label review
Species substitutionProfile differs from the declared sourceSpecies record and GC profile

Each route has a test, and no single test covers all of them. A certificate that reports only EPA, DHA and PV leaves the first, fourth and fifth routes open. Colour is the weakest signal: bleaching removes pigments, and a pale oil can still be oxidised or diluted.

Writing identity into the specification

Name the species and the source, not only “fish oil”: for example, “refined anchovy oil” or a declared blend, with the origin and the refiner. Add the form (triglyceride), the EPA and DHA ranges with the GC basis, the full profile with the minor acids that matter, free fatty acid, PV, p-AV, moisture, the contaminant panel and the fish allergen statement. State how identity is measured: GC-FAME against a certified standard, with the chromatogram on request and an intact-lipid method where the form is disputed.

A specification that says only “fish oil 30%” gives the laboratory no way to check the source, the form or the oxidation state. A specification that names the species, the form and the profile does. Those lines should appear on the certificate, with a lot code that ties the pack to the retained sample.

Five questions to put to a supplier

  1. What species and origin is the oil, and is the lot single-source or blended?
  2. Is the oil triglyceride, ethyl ester or re-esterified, and which method proves it?
  3. What are the EPA, DHA and DPA figures on the same lot, with the chromatogram and the GC basis?
  4. What are the PV, p-AV, TOTOX and free fatty acid values, with methods and production date?
  5. How is the fish allergen declared, and will you send the COA for the shipping lot?

The catalog specification is on the fish oil product page; the certificate lines are on the COA page; the grades are compared on the grades page; the oil and powder are compared on the oil versus powder page; the separation method is indexed under methods.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation