Tocopheryl succinate, acetate or tocopherol: choosing a grade
The tocopheryl succinate grade supplied here is the crystalline natural d-alpha ester, a ≥95.0% powder at 80 mesh. It is a different grade from tocopheryl acetate, which is an oil or a 50% carrier powder, and from natural tocopherol oil. The grade decision changes the physical form, the IU per gram and the label name before it changes the dose.
The succinate is the dry, crystalline ester: 95% assay, 1.21 IU per milligram and a label name that the acetate cannot fill.
Why the grade is an identity decision
Vitamin E is a family of related molecules, not one powder with several concentrations. Alpha-tocopherol is the alcohol; esterifying its phenolic hydroxyl with acetic acid gives the acetate, and esterifying it with succinic acid gives tocopheryl acid succinate. The succinate is the monoester, so one acid group stays free. That free group is why the material is a crystalline solid and only sparingly soluble in water.
The acetate carries no free acid. It is a viscous oil at room temperature, and the commercial 50% grade puts that oil on a starch carrier to make a dispersible powder. Natural tocopherol is an oil as well. The three forms have different molecular weights, different potency per milligram and different names in an ingredient list. A purchase order that says “vitamin E powder” has not chosen any of them.
The forms side by side
| Property | D-alpha-tocopheryl succinate | D-alpha-tocopheryl acetate | D-alpha-tocopherol |
|---|---|---|---|
| CAS number | 4345-03-3 | 58-95-7 | 59-02-9 |
| Formula | C33H54O5 | C31H52O3 | C29H50O2 |
| Molecular weight | 530.78 | 472.74 | 430.71 |
| Physical form | White to off-white crystalline powder | Oil, or 50% carrier powder | Yellow to amber oil |
| Water solubility | Insoluble | Practically insoluble; the 50% powder disperses | Insoluble |
| IU per mg | 1.21 | 1.36 | 1.49 |
| mg alpha-tocopherol equivalent per mg | 0.81 | 0.91 | 1.00 |
| Label name | D-alpha-tocopheryl acid succinate | D-alpha-tocopheryl acetate | D-alpha-tocopherol |
The table is the natural d series. The synthetic dl-alpha-tocopheryl acetate has its own CAS number, 7695-91-2, and 1.00 IU per mg; it is a separate grade and not interchangeable with the d forms. The IU and alpha-tocopherol equivalent figures are properties of the molecule, not values a supplier can adjust.
The powder: crystals, not a carried oil
The catalogue grade is ≥95.0% by HPLC, white to off-white, with a melting point of 73–76 °C, loss on drying ≤1.0% and ≥95% through 80 mesh. The crystals are the ester itself. There is no starch carrier and no oil phase, so the assay describes the whole powder rather than the active fraction of a diluted matrix.
The material is insoluble in water and soluble in fats and organic solvents. In water it forms a suspension that settles; it does not give a clear solution or a milky emulsion. That makes it a poor fit for a clear beverage, a stick pack or any aqueous system judged by mouthfeel, and a good fit for a two-piece capsule, a direct-compression tablet or a dry blend. The 80 mesh powder is fine and free-flowing; a granulated variant is available on request when a coarser particle is needed.
The crystalline form also sets the handling. The powder should stay sealed and dry, because moisture raises the loss on drying and can hydrolyse the ester. Heat near the melting range softens the crystals and can cake a stored drum. Caking does not change the assay at release, but it changes how the powder behaves on the line.
Dose arithmetic and the fill weight
At 1.21 IU per mg, the 95.0% powder carries 1,149.5 IU per gram. A 100 IU serving is 87 mg of powder, a 400 IU serving is 348 mg and a 1,000 IU serving is 870 mg. Those are arithmetic, not recommendations. The alpha-tocopherol equivalent is 0.81 mg per mg of succinate, so 348 mg of the 95% powder delivers about 268 mg alpha-tocopherol equivalent.
The comparison with the acetate depends on which acetate pack is on the table. The pure d-alpha acetate ester is 1.36 IU per mg, so at equal ester mass the succinate is about 11% lower in potency. But the standard acetate grade is a 50% powder at about 680 IU per gram, and that powder needs 588 mg for 400 IU. The 95% succinate needs 348 mg for the same 400 IU because it carries no starch. The succinate is less potent per milligram of ester and more concentrated per gram of commercial powder; both statements are true, and the label has to be built on the right one.
If the label names the succinate, the fill weight is calculated from the succinate assay, not from a generic “vitamin E 95%” figure. A lot near the floor and a lot several points above it need slightly different weights for the same declared dose. The certificate and the batch record should use the measured assay.
What to write into the specification
- “D-alpha-tocopheryl acid succinate (d-alpha-tocopheryl succinate), CAS 4345-03-3, C33H54O5, molecular weight 530.78.”
- “Assay ≥95.0% by HPLC; identification by HPLC retention and infrared spectrum.”
- “Melting point 73–76 °C; loss on drying ≤1.0%.”
- “Particle size ≥95% through 80 mesh; heavy metals and microbiology as listed.”
- “Potency 1.21 IU/mg and 0.81 mg alpha-tocopherol equivalent per mg, to be used in the label calculation.”
- “Pack: 1 kg foil pouch or 25 kg fiber drum; destination market and label name confirmed before the order.”
A specification that states only the assay leaves the ester, the solid form and the potency factor open. Those are the lines a substitution would have to cross.
When the succinate is the wrong grade
Do not choose the succinate for a clear drink or a high-water-activity gel. The crystals do not dissolve, and the free acid group can shift the local pH as the ester hydrolyses. Do not choose it for a softgel fill that is meant to be an oil, and do not substitute it for an acetate when the label already names the acetate. The reverse substitution is equally unsafe: an acetate powder is not a drop-in for a label that declares the succinate.
The permitted-forms list names individual tocopherol and tocopheryl forms, and a natural d-alpha succinate and a synthetic dl-succinate are not the same entry. The buyer's regulatory team confirms the entry that covers the destination before the label is fixed. The product hub carries the catalogue ranges; the vitamin E hub shows the acetate grade; the natural tocopherol page covers the oil; and the succinate versus acetate page sets out the solubility, IU and label consequences. The release tests are on the COA page.
In this document
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation